|
|
11 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Giulio, che miri?, 12 Jul 2004
As a BIG fan of Minkowski I am sorry to say that I find this recording disappointing, especially in light of his recordings of Handel's "Teseo" and "Ariodante". But then, to be fair, can any other recording ever equal or surpass Jacobs' reading of "Giulio Cesare"? It is hard to imagine. The only real star performance is delivered by the mezzo Magdalena Kozena as Cleopatra. Kozena has some difficulty sustaining the high-lying passages of this fiendish part written for Francesca Cuzzoni. Cleopatra is an interesting character on many levels. She is one of the first of Handel's three-dimensional characters. Instead of being portrayed as a young woman who matures as the opera progresses, Minkowski's Cleopatra stays at the same emotional level throughout, as he has such a mature sounding Cleopatra from the outset. Now the singing: Kozena sings with the authority of a queen. Despite her 'I think I can' high notes, her performance is more compelling, accurate, and vituosic than any other Cleopatra on record. Her big bravura aria, 'Da tempesta', is dispatched at a breakneck speed as one by now expects of Minkowski, and with such deceptive ease. At the other end her 'Se pieta' and 'Piangero' are splendid for the sheer legato and beauty of phrasing she exhibits throughout. Although she puts her soprano predecessors in this role to shame, I have to disagree with Minkowski's decision to cast a mezzo as Cleopatra: it makes Cleopatra sound too mature. So... close, but no cigar. The Giulio Cesare of Mijanovic adds nothing new to this role, if not actually detracting from his music and character. Her's is a very bland, sloppy and uninteresting performance; though I must admit that her voice is of a singular character, and has a very beautiful timbre. There is something distinctly androgynous, if not masculine, about her tone quality, yet her runs are not always accurate in intonation and articulation, and her top register is non-existant and just painful. She is also the dullest member of the cast. Why Podles was not engaged for this role can only remain a mystery. I find Bejun Mehta's Tolomeo vocally preferable to that of the other Tolomeos on record. His voice sounds like a bigger and meatier instrument, and his technique is staggering; yet he does not quite sing with the finesse of a Derek Lee Ragin. I also find that either he or Minkowski decided to reduce the character to a caricature, which is rather unfortunate as his threats can't be taken seriously. He may be cowardly, and Cleopatra does poke fun of him in the first act, but he is still a very real threat and is competent enough for his army, even if under Achilla's command, to beat the Romans in Act two. The rest of the cast, including von Otter, sing adequately, but it's nothing to write home about. Minkowski's reading adds nothing new to the score. Why this should be the case is a complete mystery, as he has a very good ensemble at his disposal. Maybe they just had an off night, as the performance in some places seems to turn into a bit of a train wreck. Here especially Mijanovic and Ewing are guilty. Even though everything is taken at a cracking pace, somehow this performance does not 'gel'. Despite my misgivings about casting a mezzo as Cleopatra and the implications it has on the character, it is worth purchasing this recording for Kozena's ravishingly sung Cleopatra. Overall the set by Rene Jacobs remains preferable.
|