|
89 of 92 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Old D'Oyly Carte, 25 Mar 2003
By A Customer
At last DECCA have gathered 15 of their finest D'Oyly Carte recordings together as a boxed set to form a more or less complete set of the Gilbert and Sullivan Operas. I say more or less as of course the G & S opus 1 (THESPIS or The Gods' Grown Old) is missing apart from two readily identifiable numbers and the ballet, although recent research indicates that much of THESPIS is still with us disguised as various numbers in THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE.The recordings presented here come partly from what was affectionately called the 'DECCA second series' recorded between 1958 and 1966, and partly from the incomplete 'DECCA third series', 1967 - 1979. It has to be said that the Second Series in general represented the company at the height of it's post-war powers and features such well-loved stalwarts as John Reed, Jean Hindmarsh, Kenneth Sandford, Joyce Wright, Thomas Round and Donald Adams. The recorded sound also is fresh and clean whereas in the third series, especially the later recordings, the sound became somewhat harsh. Of course there are personal favourites that have not been chosen for this series - PRINCESS IDA for instance is far more immediate, far better paced, in the 1953 recording, but suffers from an ageing Victoria Sladen in the title role. The 1965 recording presented here, has the advantage of Elizabeth Harwood and also the young Valerie Masterson making her recording debut as Melissa. Sir Malcolm Sargent's pacing may be more relaxed but in general this is a beautiful recording. What I cannot fully understand is the decision not to use the 1958 recordings of MIKADO and PIRATES. Both are to my mind superior to the recordings of 1973 and 1967 respectively although of course with PIRATES one does gain the dialogue, but MIKADO had the advantage of Donald Adams, Thomas Round, Ann Drummond-Grant and Isidore Godfrey. I guess it's all a matter of personal preference. The sets are beautifully packaged and feature the original (and far superior) sleve designs, a vast improvement on the slightly tacky uniform design employed for the past reissue. Some of the pairings are a bit odd - I'm sure most of those who know the operas well are used to TRIAL BY JURY paired with HMS PINAFORE and COX AND BOX paired with PIRATES, but such pairings on CD could have led to some strange mid-act disc changes. Thoroughly recommendable for anyone wishing to have all the operas from TRIAL BY JURY to THE GRAND DUKE plus COX AND BOX, THE ZOO, and a considerable amount of Sullivan's orchestral repertoire all in one place.
|
by Ian Bradley
by John Reed
~ Arthur Sullivan
~ Bernard Turgeon
![The Mikado [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41A7W323GXL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Donald Adams
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Amazon Home