Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A masterpiece ! The best martial arts film ever !, 7 Mar 2003
By A Customer
I saw this film in the early 80's and up until then, I would not have called myself a fan of martial arts films. But this film transcends the genre. If you like Crouching Tiger, then you will LOVE this. It is astonishing on every level. Considering that it was made in 69, the special effects are exceptional ! Blimey you can see the ropes in CTHD, but not here. I think CTHD was definitely influenced by this film. What I love about this film is that it starts off as a very small ghost/political thriller, and ends up as an real battle of cosmic good vs evil ! It has something I have never seen in a film since, a genuine narrative shift, seamless and yet epic. I am a real world cinema buff, but I would definitely put this in my top ten of films ever seen. Astonishing, imaginative, and a masterpiece ! I've seen and recorded it on C4, pan and scan, but I am hoping that the dvd really does some justice to it.
|
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a hidden gem for everyone..., 30 April 2003
By A Customer
This really deserved to be a more widely known film, certainly one of the gems of cinema, not showing its age despite being over thirty years old. Set in 'historical china' the story is based on folklore of: the young town scribe/artist is given a commission which takes him to the abandoned fort outside of town where he meets a princess and her aide who are on the run. They set off to find refuge being persued by various soldiers, ninja et cetera. Although there are plenty of action sequences, the three hour running time gives lots of scope for character development and stunning photogratphy of the landscapes through which the protagonists journey.This-boy meets girl, girl happens to be a princess on the run, whose only hope of safety is the sanctury of a fabled monastry and the protection its high-kicking monks can afford may sound a bit familiar and Ang Lee has specifically mentioned aToZ as the starting point of CTHD; unlike Hollywood, Hong Kong has no qualms about remaking a film to improve it rather than palming us off with degenerate sequels. But unlike CTHD there are no special effects and certianly no computer aided post production. It is also the conerstone by which much of HK's cat4 film industry judges itself. aToZ is part of the tradition of great spectacle that covers much ground without ever being in your face about any particular issues. Seemlessly moving from; old vs. new, love vs. greed to the real biggie- good vs. evil! oh and i lied about the special effects, but i don't want to spoil the gourgeous twenty minue end sequence... ENJOY!
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Great Movie, Dreadful DVD, 17 April 2009
OK, so this has been out for years, but a warning: don't buy this DVD! It's a dreadful, soft, murky TV print, squeezed into a little window with huge subtitles plonked underneath. Now way to treat any film, let along a visual masterpiece like this. The vhs I recorded off TV years ago is better (or at least, as good). Surely there must be better materials available than this? The film used to play in London cinemas at one time, for heaven's sake. There MUST be 35mm elements somewhere. The master this was taken off is many generations away from anything that looked like film. Alright, so I didn't pay much for it, but it was a major disappointment. It's a scandal that a world class film maker like King Hu is treated so shabbily on DVD. So few of his great films are available in anything like the quality they deserve. Five stars for film, no stars for DVD presentation.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|