Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
32 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A modern-styled Sheherazade, 22 Jan 2003
Having heard the Kirov Orchestra play Rimsky-Korsakov's Sheherazade several times live, during performances of the famous ballet version by Mikhail Fokine, I was quite surprised when I first listened to this CD. True, on most of these occasions the orchestra wasn't conducted by Valery Gergiev and although there is no doubt that the Kirov musicians have this music very much in their blood, this new recording won't go down as their greatest achievement.
With his unleashed, unpredictable tempi and heavy, unsubtle accents, and not helped by too much artificial reverberation obscuring instrumental detail, Valery Gergiev, whom we have heard more inspired than here, opts for an extremely rough, no-nonsense re-telling of Rimsky's ever-popular score. He seems to deny his Sheherazade every ounce of charm, poetry and sensuality, portraying a woman more likely to have spent some time in a brutal Chechnian camp than one who wallowed in the refined colours and perfumes of the Bagdad fantasized by Rimsky-Korsakov. Moreover, Gergiev doesn't avoid the pitfall of highlighting too many details of the orchestration - and true, at times he reveals unheard passages, as in the third movement - at the cost of losing grip of the overall structure. The frenzied tempo in which he attacks the last movement not only puts his orchestra in trouble, it also makes him miss the big final climax.
The orchestra's solos, the first violin from concert master Sergei Levitin to begin with, are undoubtedly commendable, but in this recording they definitely do not sound as the most sophisticated around. As is obvious from older recordings, the Kirov woodwinds surely have a lot more in store.The short fillings from Borodin and Balakirev are much in the same vein. In short, a modern-styled Sheherazade and it all depends of how you want your harem favourite to appear, but other conductors (among others Kirill Kondrashin, still unequalled for the dramatic sweep, Fritz Reiner for the sophistication of the orchestration) have given more complete and fascinating images of this wonderful work.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
brilliant (x3), 10 Mar 2007
This is a work I have known and loved for very many years. One of my first LPs was conducted by Kletzki, and I have heard many other recordings over the years; but this one surpasses them all, even Reiner and Beecham. Though tempi may be a little unusual in places - the beginning of the third section 'The Young Prince and the Princess' could be seen as on the slow side - but taken in context, the whole thing hangs together so beautifully that these things seem entirely logical. Fast passages are indeed fast, but never breathless. The Kirov players are simply superb, and Gergiev consistently shows himself to be perfectly attuned to this beautiful work.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed feelings for this Scheherazade, 17 Jun 2007
Having been an admirer of Gergiev's fresh and exciting Tchaikovsky Nutcracker, I found myself rather shortcharged after hearing his lacklustre version of Scheherazade. Despite the lavish praise that was heaped upon this version by the Penguin Guide, I found that it tended to suffer from Gergiev's mannered approach and lack of adreanaline and passion in the orchestral playing. Gergiev's performance also suffers from a cloudy and close-miked recording where one may not be able to hear the felicities and nuances of the orchestral playing because of the artificial reverb that counters the dryness of the acoustics. Nevertheless, Gergiev ably builds up climaxes slowly but steadily and keeps the architecture of Rimsky's sweltering music in shape.
Gergiev's performance begins with a lethargic rendition of the Sultan's theme, made to sound like a toothless tiger, and lacking in the menace and brutality it needs to convey its bloodthirsty nature. This is answered by Sergei Levithin's equally lethargic portrayal of Scheherazade, where her theme lacks the sinuous nature needed for her to be a seductive storyteller to the Sultan. The ensuing rendition of the first movement starts out slowly but steadily, but even so Gergiev swells the music and allows the performance to warm up when the full orchestra portrays the surging power of the sea. The Kalendar Prince movement fares slightly better, with confident orchestral playing and an exciting middle section with the sinister fanfare transformed into a march. The only demerit in this movement is that the sinister fanfare, when first introduced by the trombones, sounds like a toothles tiger and is unable to alarm the listener. The slow third movement should at least - and more fortunately - be considered a high point of the performance. Despite a slow beginning, Gergiev allows his players to shine and allows this movement to sound radiant, making for a seductive clarinet portrayal of the Young Princess and a jaunty-sounding rendition of her central theme. Gergiev's rendition of this movement is also noteworthy for the detail in the orchestral playing and for its ecstatic-sounding coda. Then, in the lively Festival at Baghdad finale, Gergiev adopts the most breakneck speed I have ever heard for this part of the work, with the Kirov Orchestra playing it until it tingles with adreanaline. At times it sounds rushed and in need of a little precision and slickness, but its only problem is that the weightless Shipwreck section makes it somewhat anticlimactic after all the excitement during the Festival. Nevertheless, Gergiev ends the work serenely and peacefuly.
The two short fill-ups benefit more in this recording, because they are given less mannered perofrmances. Nevertheless, they provide interesting couplings to Scheherazade by allowing the listener to get a taste of the Russianised Orientalism that existed before Scheherazade was written.
Overall, I wouldn't say this is an outstanding recording of Scheherazade because of its checkered effect, but at least it can't be as abominable as it is perceived to be. True, it can't top the Mercury Living Presence version with Dorati and the Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra, or the controlled yet idiomatic Russian rendition of Temirkanov on RCA, but at least it has some worthy merits that allow it to stand on its own.
|
|
|
|
~ Valery Gergiev
![New Year's Concert 2003 -- The Director's Cut [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51PCWBTWJSL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
~ Johann Sebastian Bach
~ Valery Gergiev
~ Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Make sure you always get what you want with an Amazon.co.uk 
Amazon Home