Amazon.co.uk Review
Most of the selections on Thomas Quasthoffs
Evening Star come from little-known operas, but the music is so delightful, with such a wide range of sentiment and character, that one must wonder why they are not in the standard repertoire. The title is taken from the only famous aria: the "Song to the Evening Star" from Wagners
Tannhäuser.
The programme opens with scenes from two comic operas by Albert Lortzing, who wrote his own libretti in which he parodied his characters as well as opera in general--one aria quotes a whole couplet, notes and text, from Rossinis Barber of Seville (in the German translation)--and closes with the final monologue from Richard Strausss Die schweigsame Frau. Wagner is preceded by a melodramatic aria from Carl Maria von Webers Euryanthe.
The performances are superb. Quasthoff and Thielemann work together with the rapport of kindred spirits, though this is their first collaboration, and the orchestra abets them all the way. Putting his incredibly beautiful, infinitely variable voice and consummate technique entirely at the service of words and music, Quasthoff displays an uncanny ability to bring characters instantly to life. He relishes Lortzings ironic humour and makes the frustrated rage of Webers villain quite terrifying. Fulfilling what must be every singers dream, he picks the best arias from several roles, but gives each a distinct personality. Oddly enough, the popular title piece is the only one that sounds exaggerated and artificial. The final aria is pure Straussian magic: a beautiful, simple song ending in a kind of benediction; the voice drifts away and melts into the orchestra. Unfortunately, the booklet includes no explanation of the unfamiliar operas plots.--Edith Eisler