Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
40 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Disturbing, 6 Nov 2002
Disturbing, but not in a bad way! This is one of my favourite albums of 2001. At times Guy Garvey sings like Peter Gabriel, at others the record has echoes of Bowie or Japan. These are influences, you understand, not copied motifs.The softness of the music hides an unsettling edge. This isn't merely another album of melancholic northern music, this is an album that doesn't quite let you lie back on the sofa and drift. It doesn't quite let you use it as musical wallpaper. There's something deeper there that keeps you on your toes, waiting. I bought it because I like bands like Doves and artists like Badly Drawn Boy. Elbow are somehow different. If Doves are your mate, Elbow are like their more intense older brother - the one you're a little bit scared of but you want to be liked by. You know they're related, but somewhere the gene pool got whisked around a bit. This album makes me think of wrapping up in a big thick jumper, sitting on a beach by a fire, talking to someone who has big ideas and the ability to make you dream on the same scale. The addition of Asleep In The Back on the updated version is a blessing. If you have been tempted by either Newborn or Asleep In The Back, take the plunge and buy this album. You will thank yourself for the rest of your life.
|
|
|
28 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A truly outstanding debut album, 30 April 2001
By A Customer
By their own admission, Elbow are "prog-rock without the solos" and many others have labelled them as "Doves 2001" - but as this debut proves, they are so much more. "Asleep In The Back" is based around lead singer Guy's distinct genuine hold to every song on it - his honesty and his humble desire to portray the trials and tribulations of himself and his band turns this album into a very real treat. The singles give a good impression of what to expect on the LP - "New Born" with its fragile beauty, "Any Day Now" with its dark melancholy, and "Red" as a brilliantly structured song both lyrically and musically. However, the clear album highlight "Powder Blue" is all these and more and a strong contender for song of the year. "Asleep In The Back" falls nothing short of reminding us that there's still a place in this nu-metal obsessed world for acoustic music with heart-breakingly down-to-earth lyrics. Little surprise really, with musicians as crafted and experienced as Elbow, anything less would be a disappointment. An absolute pleasure to listen to from start to finish.
|
|
|
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Debut of the highest quality, 30 Nov 2002
"Any day now, How's about getting out of this place? Anyways, Got a lot of spare time, Some of my youth, And all of my senses on overdrive" So goes the incredibly addictive refrain of Asleep in the Back's opening track Any Day Now. Yes, it's proggy and more than a little murky, but as with all the songs on this album, the longing heart shines through. This must in main be put down to Guy Garvey's superlative voice. Quite simply no-one can currently match him. Avoiding the histrionics of Starsailor's James Walsh, his voice is never less than warm and inviting, whatever he's singing, even the naked opening lines to Newborn, the album's highlight: "I'll be the corpse in your bathtub, Useless".
The contribution by Garvey's fellow musicians can not be understated. Whereas most bands now rip open the Beatles songbook for a riff, randomly hit the top string of the bass, and feel they have a song, Elbow carefully construct layered masterpieces. Nothing is out of place. The counterpoint backing melodies are superb. Pretty, picked acoustic guitars form the background to every song. Jupp's drumming is nothing less than a revelation. This is pretensionless prog, which before now seemed something of a contradiction in terms.
Comparisons with Radiohead are frankly bizarre. Kid A is the only thing that comes remotely close to it. And even then, Kid A is mostly harsh, often alienating music, far from the tender beauty of Elbow. On the quieter songs Elbow sound like a slightly more inventive Coldplay, which is a complement that serves them no justice whatsoever. The singles in Britain were impeccably chosen: Red, the gorgeous Powder Blue (complete with sad, lonely saxophone) and Newborn are the most accessible songs on the album, and highlight the power and fragility which colours all of this work. They pave the way for more rumbling, almost tribal hymns like Any Day Now, Little Beast and Bitten by the Tailfly, which has a stinging, electrified guitar burst which is possibly the most exciting moment of any album released this year. The bonus track which was not originally included on the first pressing of the album is confusingly also titled Asleep in the Back. It is a gentle, sighing waltz, and a gratefully received addition.
My favourite moment? On Coming Second, Garvey's words tumble down the melody and cry out with just a hint of bitterness and incredulity "Best dishevelled lover 3 years running, Coming second to, A picket fence white, nine to five, Who's just alive".
It is one of several heart-stopping moments on an album that lingers in the memory long after it has been played.
Guy Garvey is a new, original lyricist with the voice of the decade, backed by a new, exciting band. They deserve to take all before them.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
