Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A good premise and then this one goes right down the tubes, 31 Jul 2004
Actually, the initial link between "Book of Shadows" and "The Blair Witch Project" is pretty good, especially when you think about the problems Hollywood would have coming up with a sequel to the most successful Independent film of all time (although it is about to get passed by "My Big Fat Greek Wedding," which is just so ironic on so many levels). After all, you cannot simply find another bunch of film left behind from another bunch of young documentarians who disappear while wandering around lost in the woods. So the idea of having the second movie follow around a small group of people who thought the first movie was real is pretty inspired. I am sure we all know someone who swallowed "The Blair Witch Project" promotional routine hook, line and sinker (I will never forget the look on my oldest daughter's face when I told her the movie was a "fake"; after all, she saw the documentary on television...), so this is a pretty good idea. However, one good idea does not a good movie make.My expectations for the second Blair Witch film as soon as I heard once was planned was simply that we were going to actually SEE something this time around. "The Blair Witch Project" is one of the great shaggy dog stories of all time. You keep waiting for something big to happen and it really never does. A ghostly white figure in the distance would have been something to freak everybody out, but the two big moments of that first film come down to untying a dirty bundle (and saying to yourself "ewww...what the hell are those things?" because you are not sure) and a guy standing in a corner (which is set up by the only post production bit of filming in the movie). So, I figured that like the difference between "Halloween" and "Halloween II," we would be seeing a lot more in "Book of Shadows." While this is certainly true on one level, in terms of half naked bodies at least, this sequel ends up resembling "Halloween III," the infamous horror film sequel that had pretty much nothing to do with the original. Think about it: take away the opening of this film where the Blair Witch tour begins and the connections between the two films becomes extremely tenuously, especially once these poor young things end up holed up in a building rather than being lost in the woods. Yes, "Book of Shadows" certainly has a more explicit punch line than "The Blair Witch Project," but once again you end up sitting there going "Wha-at?" This is not only becomes the film has been messing with your mind (seeing is not to be confused with believing), but also because whatever evil is behind the bad things that happen in this film is clearly not the same evil that was behind the first one. You have to admit that there is a qualitative difference between hanging stick figures from trees in the deep woods or leaving a bunch of cut up corpses on Coffin Rock and the mondo mind-bending that happens in this film. However, I do have to admit that there was one other good idea it this film, which was that this group does indeed find some film of their jaunt through the woods: but it is of themselves doing weird, wild, wacky things the night before that none of them remember. Unfortunately, this is not a set up for something great, but rather a clue as to what is "really" going on. After this effort it should be impossible for them to come up with a "Blair Witch 3" off of this one, which is no big loss. The original has its nice little niche in horror film history and that will just have to do
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Film, 21 Oct 2003
I think this film is really good, the directors could of easily made another rehash of The Blair Witch Project but instead decided to try a different angle.The Plot : 4 people (Steven, Trysten, Kim and Erica) are led by a tour guide (Jeff) on a Blair Witch Hunt. After partying till late they wake up and find their equiptment trashed and their belongings in shreds. They then try to descover what happened. One of the best features of this film is the soundtrack featuring songs by Poe, Marilyn Manson, Nickleback, Godhead and At The Drive In. DVD Special Features :- The Secrets Of Esrever (Reverse) - After watching the film you will see a message and a few video clips, follow this, take down the letters and it points out ghostly goings on within the film. Directors Commentary - Very good and informative, not just about the film but production etc as well. 2 "Documantaries" - One examines the man being put on trial (Jeff) and how the cas was being investigated and interviews. The other is about the 7 children that were murdered. Trailers (2) - A teaser trailer and a theatrical trailer. Live Music Video - Godhead performing "The Reckoning" live at the Blair Witch Hunt. Biographies - Biographis of stars, cast and crew etc. Interviews - Interviews with 4 of the stars, short and sweet and quite informative. Audio and Visual : The audio is fantastic and every ghostly voice sounds amazing, while the film is presented in the widescreen format. All In All : A good solid film backed up by some amazing special features.
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Shadows can be good, 4 Sep 2003
To expect anyone to match the 'uniqueness' of the original Blair Witch is a phenominal ask indeed. The 'original' Blair Witch was just that.....an original, and you do not duplicate originals. The challenge in conceptualizing such a plot is huge, since the 'reality' element (or as some would prefer to call it 'mockumentary' element) could no longer be duplicated. I think it was a clever idea to point a finger at the first movie and distnace the plot from it considerably, along with the manner in which the movie was executed. Nevertheless, the movie manages to stay true to the essence of what made the original a success, i.e. the eerieness and creepiness. The Blair Witch series is not about blood and gore in your face, its about leaving the horror to your imagination: afterall, what could be more scarier than the imagination itself. The movie will coax you and guide you into the shadows and fears of your mind....and you will love the movie for it! With reference to the special features, the 'Secret of Reverse' is an interesting piece, and will engross the willing into delving even deeper into the cult that is the Blair Witch. If you liked the original because you thought it was a 'true story', then skip the sequel. If you liked it for its 'originality' and ability to scare in the absence of blood, gore, a soundtrack and the works....then yes, go for it!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|