|
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An eclectic disc unfortunately let down by a few tracks, 11 Dec 2001
Anybody who knows Angela Gheorghiu's work will know that she makes a brilliant heroine, her powerful voice has the ability to transport the listener right into the heart of the piece and the drama conveyed in her voice is incredible. In the four Romanian songs at the beginning of this disc her voice fits perfectly, the passion she has for the songs of her homeland is highly evident and takes her performance to another level. This disc starts brilliantly, easily five-star material, unfortunately the early promise is not upheld.Her performance of Adam's "O holy night" has the same power and drama as her operatic heroines, however, this is not fitting to the music which comes across as forced and overpowered. The same can be said for the Pie Jesu from the Faure Requiem which is, unfortunately, one of the worst renditions I have ever heard on a commercially released CD. The "Quia respexit" from Bach's Magnificat is also slightly over operatic at the beginning and sounds too full at the entry of the Romanian National Chamber Choir who, whilst producing a very pleasing sound, are perhaps not best suited to Bach. The Schubert "Ave Maria" is well performed by the choir but Gheorghiu's voice sounds a little 'forced' at times and the tenderness never quite comes through leaving the music sounding somewhat 'caged'. Bhrams' "Wiegenlied" shows that there is a marvellously tender side to Gheorghiu and her performance of Schubert's "Mille cherubini in coro" is extraordinarily beautiful as are Mendelssohn's "Auf Fluugeln des Gesanges" and Puccini's "Salve regina". Gheorghiu's rendition of the Mascagni "Ave Maria" is simply divine and must be one of the best performances I have ever heard combining Gheorghiu's power and dramaticism with amazingly tender singing in just the right proportions. Gheorghiu is wonderfully suited to Niedermeyer's "Pieta, Signore" and it shows here with a magnificent rendition. The disc ends with a delightfully dramatic and heartfelt performance of Wade's "Adeste, fideles" (better known as the carol "O Come All Ye Faithful!"). Overall, a disc well worth getting but there are a few downsides.
|