Amazon.co.uk Review
As
Wonderland illustrates, consistency has never been one of The Charlatans' virtues. Their back catalogue includes one or two albums that sound like they were touched by the hand of the almighty-1997's
Tellin' Stories, especially, is something of a classic-and several which struggle to offer a convincing case for their existence.
Wonderland sadly falls firmly into the latter category. The tone is set by the opening track, "You're So Pretty--We're So Pretty", an extraordinarily annoying melding of INXS-style white-socked funk and the sort of mannered falsetto vocal that Mick Jagger was insisting upon circa
Tattoo You. Indeed, the unfathomable decision of singer Tim Burgess to venture outside his usual limited range is one of the principal deficiencies of
Wonderland-it doesn't do single "Love Is The Key" or the otherwise engaging
Primal Scream-ish shuffle "I Just Can't Get Over Losing You" any favours, either. There are a couple of points at which The Charlatans lock into the lolloping groove and lightness of touch that made
Tellin' Stories such a great album, but these serve mostly as a reminder of what is missing. The Charlatans'
Wonderland has been reached via a wrong turning. --
Andrew Mueller
CD Description
'Wonderland' is the Charlatans' eighth album and first new material since the 1999 release 'Us And Us Only'. A combination of rock, soul and funk, with influences of Curtis Mayfield and The Rolling Stones. Includes the single 'Love Is The Key'.