Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Drama but influenced by hindsight fed anti-Scott bias, 14 Feb 2005
Having watched this series 20 years ago, I tracked it down via Amazon and was delighted when I found it, and, in comparison with 2001's 'Shackleton,' it has aged quite well, apart from the soundtrack, which does sound dated.I dare say that anyone buying this DVD will already know a fair bit of Antarctic Exploration History, and will thus be able overlook some of the inventions of the script. There are some excellent performances here, from the lead characters of Martin Shaw as Scott and Sverre Anker Ousdal as Amundsen, to Richard Morant as Captain Oates and a splendidly embittered performance from Bill Nighy as Cecil Meares. There's also an appearance from a youthful Hugh Grant as Apsley Cherry-Garrard. The scenery is magnificent, and the cast convey at least something of an idea of how hard life was for early polar explorers. However, like 'Shackleton,' there is a little too much build up and more important events hardly touched on - Lashly, Crean and Evans' hazardous return to base, (with Crean's heroic 30 mile solo trek to Hut Point) is probably worth a film of its own It is a pity that this otherwise excellent drama, and the final episode in particular, was based upon Roland Huntford's biased 'Scott and Amundsen,' now largely discredited (by Ranulph Fiennes' 'Captain Scott' and Susan Solomon's 'The Coldest March'). As such, the conclusion reflects the inaccurate and scurvy-obsessed theories of a journalist (Huntford) who has never been in such a situation. In fact, neither Scott or Amundsen are portrayed sympathetically here, and one is left feeling that the casual viewer would have gone away with an unfairly negative view of both these heroic men. This DVD set is well packaged but there are no extras. My supposed Region 1 copy played perfectly well on a Region 2 only player for some reason!
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Myth-exploding epic series of man vs. nature& man vs. man.., 15 Dec 2004
This 7 part series dramatises Amundsen and Scott's race to the South Pole in 1911-1912. Filmed in tandem, the two parties never meet or interact (apart from one brief incident)and the Norwegian's are shown to be cooler, more prepared, less egotistic and more respectful of the extremity of nature that Antarctica presents, hence their success. When first broadcast by ITV in 1985, this lavish revisionist production was heavily criticised for showing Captain Scott's legendary heroics to be nothing more than arrogance and stupidity, costing the lives of four men as well as his own. It also unsparingly (and controversially) showed Scott's men deteriorating before your eyes from scurvy (ghastly in the final scenes). The locations are wonderfully achieved and this looks even more real than the more recent Shackleton series. The acting is also very strong. Martin Shaw's Scott is one of his finest creations, and Stephen Moore is memorable as Dr Wilson. Other star turns come from Bill Nighy, Hugh Grant and Michael Maloney. But special praise should go to Richard Morant as Captain Oates, whose understated suffering and common-sense musings go unheeded. Only Sylvester Mccoy seems miscast. He acts the part of Bowers well enough but he simply can't suggest Bowers' immense physical strength and fortitude (Although very short, the real life Bowers was seemingly immune to frost-bite and fatigue!) Any TV programme that dramatises a 2000-mile journey made on foot without the luxury of rescue parties or resupply of food and fuel is something out of the ordinary. And that's before you take into account -60 degree temperatures and 70mph winds! Overall, this is the kind of TV that is rarely made these days. Not dumbed-down, not Americanised, not afraid to tackle an epic theme. DVD transfer is acceptable rather than spectacular and sound is in mono. But it looks good and some location shots of pack ice and glaciers are beautiful.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"Scott killed himself. That's what the British do best.", 2 Sep 2006
The Last Place On Earth is a now forgotten British mini-series that's worth remembering. Based on Roland Huntford's still controversial myth-shattering biography of Scott and Amundsen's race to the South Pole, it's the kind of thing which would be done in a rushed 2-3 hours at most today, but in 1985 got more than twice that running time over seven episodes. The benefits are amazing. It may take three episodes for the rivals to hit Antarctic waters, but Trevor Griffiths' excellent script, despite a few liberties with history, chronology and supporting characters (particularly Frederick Cook, himself prone to dramatic license), has enough room for its characters' flaws and virtues to be fully explored and quietly builds up real involvement. Martin Shaw's Scott gets most of the flaws, though the show doesn't go quite so overboard with them as Huntford's book (to be fair, Scott's pomposity and ability to repeat disastrous mistakes gave him lots of ammo). But despite being played rather superbly with a charismatic twinkle in his eye by Sverre Anker Ousdal, Amundsen isn't perfect either, as his disastrously mismanaged false start and his jealousy and antagonism toward a more famous member of his expedition demonstrate. Although the story doesn't allow it to be explored, the final episode contains plenty of hints of the bitter man he would eventually become as his victory was increasingly overshadowed by the `glory' of Scott's failure.
Ferdinand Fairfax's direction is impressively cinematic, one episode boasting a complex uninterrupted travelling take that's almost up there with Touch of Evil if only on a technical level. There's a lot of familiar British actors when they were still little-knowns among the supporting cast - Hugh Grant, Bill Nighy, Michael Maloney, Pat Roach, Richard Wilson and one of the lesser Dr Whos, Sylvester McCoy (excellent here) among them - as well as the one-time star of guilty pleasure Song of Norway, Toralv Maurstead, looking considerably older than his years as an ill-starred member of Amundsen's expedition (for once, with the exception of Max Von's Sydow's Nansen, the Norwegians are played by real Norwegians). Per Theodor Haugen also makes his mark as Amundsen's brother, constantly left to deal with the details and itinery of the everyday life the explorer cannot deal with. There are a couple of moments that don't really work - Scott glimpsing what he thinks is a cross at Cape Evans where his own memorial would later stand is shot far too literally and the very 80s rock scoring of Amundsen crossing the mountains to the plateau is horribly sub-Chariots of Fire - and none of Amundsen's team on the Polar trek itself ever become characters in their own right, but they're minor flaws. This has a 9.4 rating on the IMDB. It earned it.
Thankfully, unlike some recent mini-series releases, the NTSC release hasn't been crudely cropped in fake widescreen but is in its original fullframe ratio, with all seven episodes presented with opening and closing titles over three discs. The quality isn't demo standard, but that's partially down to the original filmstock that was used (its look is typical of 70s-80s British TV), although the picture quality is noticeably sharper in the last two episodes. No extras.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![The Last Place On Earth [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51EDD847DRL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Rhodes [2008] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51mae-DdyoL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Judge John Deed - Complete BBC Series 3 & 4 [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/510wHvQojHL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
With an Amazon.co.uk 
