Amazon.co.uk Review
Play Dead is Astrid's second album and--rather like their first--casts them as toddler-like pretenders to
Teenage Fanclub's golden throne. Indicatively, several abundantly hummable songs--the albums's title track and the single "Tick Tock" for example--champion traditional pop values to excellent effect. But, oh, for a little more individuality. The nagging suspicion that Astrid are playing their cards too far away from their chest becomes apparent on "It Never Happened", which recalls Dodgy circa 1993, and "Wrong For You" which is
Shack's "Cornish Town" with extra clotted-cream and an all too similar Simon and Garfunkel vocal coda. The albums' standout track, the playful "Horror Movies", couldn't be any more like the
Fountains of Wayne if it was written and performed by the Fountains of Wayne. Hang on, that's a real compliment.
--Kevin Maidment