|
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two excellent films from 1916 for the price of one, 8 April 2006
D W Griffith was provoked into creating Intolerance by the substantial numbers of vocal protesters against his incredibly successful 1915 film "Birth of a Nation".Intolerance is actually four films set at different periods in history supposedly illustrating the evils of intolerance, and we are cut from one film to another throughout the three hours running time. Fortunately the DVD permits us to view each film separately, and after an initial viewing as Griffith intended I think this is the way to go. Griffith's extraordinary concept was beyond the understanding of critics in 1916, and as a result audiences stayed away in droves and the film was probably one of the two greatest box flops in film history, it was sixty four years before the second one in 1980 "Heavens Gate". However history belies the fact that "Intolerance" includes two excellent feature length films (subsequently released separately), "The Mother and the Law" set in 1916" and "The Fall of Babylon" set in Old Testament times, and two shorts, a French story set in 1592 about the massacre of the Huguenots, and a very fragmentary Judean short about the crucifixion. "The Mother and the Law" stars Mae Marsh and Robert Harron excellent as a couple whose lives are destroyed in a drama about a group of wealthy "do gooder" women. "The Fall of Babylon" is a biblical epic with sets of awesome magnitude and a cast of thousands, starring Constance Talmadge (sister of Norma Talmadge) who steals the acting honours as the feisty "Mountain Girl" from Alfred Paget as Belshazzar and Seena Owen as his Princess. The "French Story" is a competent short of the time, and the "Judean" story is probably best forgotten. So two excellent silent films (in very good transfers from a good but not perfect source) for the price of one plus an offbeat piece of cinematic history as well.
|