Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Stellar compositions., 29 Aug 2003
Mark Knopfler obviously loves to write passacaglias - pieces of music that start with a very basic theme, played by only one or very few instruments and, often over repeated crescendos and slow-downs, increasing in volume and instrumentation to a rousing finale, performed by either all instruments or the instrumental lead "voice;" in Knopfler's case of course his trademark Fender Strat. "Brothers in Arms" has elements of a passacaglia, and so does "Speedway to Nazareth" on his 2000 solo release, "Sailing to Philadelphia." His greatest achievement though, not only in this regard, has to be "Telegraph Road," the opening track of "Love Over Gold." In a little over 14 minutes, the song rises from a simple opening melody, evoking the loneliness of that man walking along a deserted track at the beginning of the song's story, to a final guitar solo which is among the most ambitious and evocative pieces of music written by anyone in recent decades, anywhere and in any musical category. In between, there are no less than two other guitar solos, each of them over a minute long; dramatic centerpieces in their own right in any song but this one. And like the song's instrumentation, its lyrics trace the story of civilization from that one man walking along a track to a modern city, with six lines of traffic (three lines moving slow), unemployment, desolation and anger; so apparent in Knopfler's coarse vocals in the final verse and echoed with even greater force in the instrumental finale. "Telegraph Road" is followed by the sinister "Private Investigations," reminiscent of Alan Parsons's interpretation of the Poe classic "Tales of Mystery and Imagination" (listen to that steady beat underneath the instrumental part and tell me you don't hear the "Tell Tale Heart"), and as daring and elaborate in its composition as "Telegraph Road." Both pieces are made possible by the advent of Alan Clark and his skills as a pianist; and yet, here as there it is Knopfler's guitar play that takes front and center stage. Next is the wicked "Industrial Disease," followed by the album's title track, and last, "It Never Rains," Knopfler's bow to Bob Dylan, rendered in an interpretation so true to life that you inadvertently feel yourself transported back by a decade or more and expect him switch into "The Times They Are A-Changin'" any second. One may wonder why the record, given its mostly gloomy and cynical mood, was not named for one of the two equally stunning and dark first tracks. Perhaps, however, the answer lies in the title song's last verse: "It takes love over gold and mind over matter to do what you do that you must, when the things that you hold can fall and be shattered or run through your fingers like dust." The album's cover rightly (although somewhat unnecessarily) describes "Love Over Gold" as "one of Dire Straits' most ambitiously conceived projects to date" and points out that it "reflects almost a year's worth of meticulous attention." Short of his film music (which he was not to start writing until a year later, with "Local Hero"), this album was the closest yet that Knopfler has come to classical composition; not just in the record's first two masterpieces but right down to little details like the xylophone air underneath the title track. It was a hard act to follow, even for a Mark Knopfler; and his virtually only choice was to take his music into other, and more diverse directions ("Brothers in Arms"). Listening to the remastered CD version of "Love Over Gold," you almost forget that unlike its mega-selling successor this recording was not "made for CD;" which in itself speaks volumes to the quality of the sound engineering and production and, more importantly, to the indeed "meticulous attention" given to every single instrumental and human voice of every single track on the album. In all of its 41+ minutes, and although it does not reflect as wide a range of musical styles as Knopfler’s later work, "Love Over Gold" is one of the most complex pieces of recording he ever produced. It may have taken the release of "Brothers in Arms" to propel Dire Straits to worldwide fame forever. But it is impossible to listen to "Love Over Gold" and not recognize the unique talent of a man who, having found an initial foothold in the musical scene through the success of his band's first three albums, here made it clear once and for all just how much more the world had yet to expect from him.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Masterpiece, 30 Jul 2003
1982: Dire Straits have guitars, drums, keyboards and bucketloads of talent, but most importantly they have something to sing about. There are only five tracks here, but each is in its own way a landmark work. It's not particularly happy stuff, despite sparkling dynamics, but it has unavoidable pull.A lot of things have been said about Eighties music. Before you believe any of them, listen to Love over Gold. This is Dire Straits' masterpiece album, which makes the achievement of a follow-up album in the form of Brothers in Arms all the more significant. And, as we know, that was truly an act that couldn't be followed. Where did they go? You can almost hear a prophecy of their fate in the soul-stirring monster that is Telegraph Road. For maximum emotional impact, best consumed with something nostalgic from the era, perhaps Halo Jones.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Absolutely brilliant, a masterpiece, 6 April 2004
By A Customer
Late 1982 and Dire Straits were exceedingly popular at this point when they released their 4th album. This one is predominantly dark in tone and there are only five tracks on 'Love Over Gold', the but don't let that put you off. The album runs for over 41 minutes and the songs are among the finest that Mr Knopfler ever wrote and produced. 'Making Movies' was a fine album however this one is even better.Knopfler had started to experiment more by this time. The lyrics are excellent and every song tells a story. By now they had a permanent keyboard player and a new guitarist in the line up as well as Knopfler, John Illsley and drummer Pick Withers. The almost 15 minute long 'Telegraph Road' is a superb track from beginning to end. The instrumentals are lengthy but they never tire. The sinister 'Private Investigations' was the hit single which nearly made it to number one (kept off by Survivor). It became a favourite at their concerts. 'Industrial Disease' is a fine song as well; the dark theme of industrial strife in a town is dealt with in a humourous way, perhaps satirical even. The title track never sounded better than on here in its original studio form, and features an excellent instrumental with Knopfler on acoustic guitar. The last track 'It Never Rains', is dark in tone again, perhaps angry even. It starts off quietly then really takes off half way through. Produced by Mark Knopfler. 'Love Over Gold' is a classic album, easily the best of Dire Straits' early work, and is actually better than the subsequent live album. The remastered version enhances the quality of the tracks and out of all their back catalogue this one and 'Brothers In Arms' easily come on top and are a must-have for any serious music listener.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|