Amazon.co.uk Review
The Alfred Hitchcock thriller
Marnie was savaged by critics on its original release in 1964, but has since established a cult reputation. It should be pointed out, however, that its current fans are mostly university teachers who spin convoluted theories (often derived from Freudian psychoanalysis) in order to lend authority to a rather simple tale. Watch the movie and judge for yourself whether it's a profound experience or just Hitchcock scraping the bottom of the barrel. Tippi Hedren stars as the title character, a compulsive thief whose
modus operandi is to land a secretarial job, bilk her employer of thousands, then change identity (and hair tone) before proceeding to the next scam. Sean Connery plays Mark Rutland, a wealthy businessman who finds Marnie's larcenous habits strangely erotic. He marries her and gradually sniffs out a repressed childhood trauma or two.
Reviewers lambasted the film for its technical shoddiness--and indeed, it's hard to ignore the ugly painted backdrop in one street scene or the crudely obvious rear-projection when Marnie goes horseback riding. Latter-day apologists have argued these effects are deliberately phoney and unrealistic, meant to portray the heroine's subconscious fantasies. While you might have a tough time swallowing that one, there is no denying that Marnie supplies plenty of ammunition for armchair shrinks. Go and figure why our light-fingered lassie flips out each time she spies the colour red or what lies behind her sexual frigidity. It is also well known that Hitchcock developed a morbid crush on the leading lady and showered her with unwelcome attentions during the course of filming. Despite her ordeal (or perhaps because of it), Hedren matches the blankly unemotional performance she gave for Hitchcock in The Birds (1963) Yet somehow her cold, mask-like beauty adds a cryptic note which is utterly appropriate to the story. Similarly, the film itself is perhaps more enjoyable to think about afterwards than when you are actually seeing it. But its very sluggishness and lack of coherence lend it a surreal, dream-like quality that's hard to forget. --Peter Matthews
Synopsis
Marnie suffers with nightmares, a tendency to steal and a hatred of men. Her husband attempts to unlock the door to her past. Includes the theatrical trailer.