Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great - The Stuff of Comic Books, 29 Oct 2003
Why moan about plot, poor scripts, etc. Silver Nemesis is pure comic book adventure. The Doctor and Ace are a great double act, neither of them worried about getting dirty or wet when diving for cover during the battle scenes. OK, the battle scenes in Silver Nemesis may not be on the scale of a Hollywood blockbuster, but remember, it was only a three episode BBC TV programme with a limited budget. Besides, who wants to see blood and guts all over the screen, AND it was also pre-watershed family viewing. The Cybermen may not have been as menacing as in Earthshock, but if you recall, one of the Cybermen was killed by using Adric's gold star, so why shouldn't Ace be able to kill them with gold coins and a catapult! I grew up watching Dr Who, I still remember watching the very first episode as a boy, and Silver Nemesis is good old-fashioned Dr Who fair at its best. Did one reviewer get mixed up? The episode where the Doctor and Ace pay £5 for drinks was Battlefield. When you watch Silver Nemesis listen out during the scene in the crypt where the German soldier knocks a Cyberman to the ground. I'm sure I heard the Cyberman say 'OW' as he hit the floor!
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pure Silver, 5 May 2009
It's a shame that Amazon's image for this is so poor - the box cover is green and silver and looks really cool.
I totally agree with BlindBadger on this one; it's an anniversary story and therefore should have as much packed in as possible - plot's not overly important in Doctor Who folks so it's no good us fans getting our knickers in a twist about it! What's important is colourful scintillating entertainment - and this VHS provides that in bucketfuls. With guest stars of the calibre of the (apparently very difficult to work with) Anton Diffring, as a Nazi war criminal, and Gerard Murphy as a man literally out of time, this is a top-notch adventure. Ok, I know the series was supposed to be fun AND educational, but surely we can forgive the production team here; at least it's fun!
Great making-of too; but Gary Downie really ought to have been censored for that terrible shirt!
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Use your imagination :D, 5 May 2009
I dunno, I just don't get all this criticism. It's Doctor Who people, it's fun and exciting and has the best Doctor and companion pairing since, in my opinion, William Hartnell and Ian/Barbara.
All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed this tale and since purchasing this video I know that it'll be a serial I'll watch more than just a couple of times. This video also made me realise why I'm not so much of a fan of these later Doctors because I think the charm that was Doctor Who seems to be seriously lacking. Oh they might have a joke here and there and all that, but it seems to me as if the PTBs (Russell T Davies at least) have decided to make it all rather serious and turn the Doctor into, primarily, an obvious, blatant, melancholic, hypocritical, wet blanket.
Bring back these fun filled, exciting adventures where you can just sit back and let your imagination run away with you, and not be steeped knee-deep in special effects that simply kills your imagination in an instant. Bring back this kind of Doctor where the melancholy and loneliness is subtle and not shoved in your face.
Anyway, sorry about the semi-rant, I do though highly recommend this video to anyone, especially for the "Making of" - It was very interesting to see the inner workings and what not, and you also get to see the fun everyone has while making it - and I think the frustrations as well.
High recommendation from me
:-)
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|