|
49 of 52 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wish They Were Here, 2 Mar 2004
Despite the daunting prospect of having to follow ‘Dark Side of The Moon’, ‘Wish You Were Here’ rises to the challenge admirably. What it lacks in dynamics and interplay it more than makes up for in tension and control.Nowhere is this more evident than in the album’s first four minutes, where David Gilmour’s taut guitar and Rick Wright’s keyboard chords stretch the suspense to breaking point and beyond before Gilmour finally provides exquisite relief with a simple, unadorned four note arpeggio. That sets the mournful tone of ‘Shine On You Crazy Diamond’, an epic 26-minute eulogy to Syd Barrett (a former member of Pink Floyd, put simply) that starts and bookends the album and is arguably the finest track the band have ever produced. While the ghost of Syd hovers above many a Floyd album, ‘Shine On You Crazy Diamond’ is the only track that is specifically about Syd, celebrating the genius that leaked into madness while mourning his loss to the band. Roger Waters’ lyrics and the band’s playing are so complimentary it hurts. Between the two parts of the epic are two rants against the system – the acerbic ‘Welcome To The Machine’ and the humorously cynical ‘Have A Cigar’ (sung by Roy Harper) – and the simple, melancholic, acoustic title track which neatly sums up how the band were feeling at the time. Despite Waters’ growing dominance over the band, ‘Wish You Were Here’ is still very much a Pink Floyd album, with all the instrumental elements contributing to the overall sound. It may not have the spark and fizz of ‘Dark Side of The Moon’, but in other ways it cuts deeper. For David Gilmour and Rick Wright, it’s their favourite Pink Floyd album.
|