Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Magnificent, Terryfing, Brilliant, Splendid, 30 Dec 2000
This is the best recording of "Il Trovatore" ever known to me. The reason is simple. Here you can find every performer perfectly suitable to their roles and the most suitable to his "role" is Herbet von Karajan. I think that "Trovatore" is his opera. He is capable of doing some outstanding conducting. Starting with the first scene. What a magnificent performing by the orchestra! Especially the closing moments. I've never heard anything like that and belive me, I've heard a lot. Then comes chorus of zingara, brilliant. What a sound! From my childhood I go mad about this scene. Splendid! Now lets talk about the performers. Let me start with the ladies. Leontyne Price is the best Leonora of the 20th century. She is so great. Starting with "Tacea notte placida..." and finishing with "Manrico, addio..." every sound produced by her is beyond the capability of human voice. She's never casual with her high notes, everything is brilliant. Elena Obraztsova, my favourite mezzo, is, I believe, the best Azucena of the 20th century. I've heard many outstanding mezzos in this role, Cossotto, Barbieri, Simionatto, but Elena's voice is the most suitable for Azucena's tragic personality. Listen to her when she's singing "Stride la vampa..." and finally comes "Il figlio mio, il figlio mio...". Everything is perfect, her high notes are great and her low register is like a stone. She's got the strongest low register among all mezzos. Manrico is Franco Bonisolli one of the most suitable roles. He's cabaletta is brilliant, full of passion and voice, his high C is outstanding. Many people say that he's got the finest and easiest high C among the 20th century tenors. Listen and judge. Piero Cappuccilli is the best Di Luna of the 20th century. Sometimes too rough, still he is brilliant. Listen to him in first act trio, his aria in second act. his "No, giammai" in the final scene of the second act. What can I say? this is the best recording of "Trovatore", must have. I really enjoy it.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The perfect Il Trovatore, 20 Feb 2006
I could not agree more with the reviewer before me - this is one of the best, and probably THE best, Il Trovatore ever recorded. Karajan's conducting has a great sense of drama and does justice to the score in every possible way. The tempo is considerably slower than I hear this opera usually conducted, but after you get used to the pace you will be thrilled by the way he extends the most important musical moments of the piece. The very finale of the opera for example sends shivers down my spine every time I hear it, with the right time and attention given to the final utterances of the principals, so often abrupt and rushed through. Or the sweet but yet horrifying Leonora's Miserere, with the monks' chorus just brilliantly following her... under Karajan you can really feal the plasticity and structure of the score.
The principals are outstanding, and do an outstanding job at following the demandingly slow and original conducting. Azucena is one of my favourite of Verdi's roles and Obraztsova's interpretation here is just incredible. Her rendition of "Condotta ell'era in ceppi" is the most dramatic and terrifying that I have ever heard. But apart from her incredible chest register, she is notable for three things: the power of her voice (that penetrates through all choruses and orchestral walls), technical perfection and the moving sadness she brings to the role. Do not fear, her Azucena is as violently mad as ever, but she brings that often overlooked sad maternal love and vulnerability to "Giorni povera vivea" and to the confrontation with the Count. Azucena becomes more than a strange witch, but also a shattered and traumatised woman. Her final cry "Manrico! where is my son?" is heart-breaking. Leonora is arguably a less complex character, but Leontyne Price is absolutely outstanding in the role that has always been one of her fortes. A lot of Leonora's singing is in a comparably low register, and Price's versatile voice is as at home there as in the high thrills, not to mention the never pathetic emotion she so easily reads into the part. You will not be able to get enough of her in this role. Bonisolli as Manrico is great, the slightly darker colour of his voice very suitable to this temperamental role. What I find with many singers (e.g. recently with Roberto Alagna) is that they sing this role as if Manrico is angry all the time, but Bonisolli reads a lot of tenderness into bits such as his love aria in Act 3, or his "Riposa o madre" duet with Azucena, which becomes a moving little lullaby (you can't scream "Go to sleep" to someone can you?). His "Di Quella Pira" is as good as any, and not rushed through as with some conductors who fear their singers will not be able to hold the high notes for long enough. Cappuccilli, one of my favourite baritones, is a superb Count, nothing to say apart from that he gets it right.
All in all, the great interpretative ability of all of the singers and Karajan's interesting and blastingly dramatic conducting make this mid-price cd a must-have. Even if you already own a recording or two of this opera, you will not be sorry for getting this one.
|
|
|
2.0 out of 5 stars
leontyne price - Il Trovatore, 14 Mar 2009
As good as she is, she is over 50 here. And it shows it in her voice. Her recording of the arias with the Arturo Basile on the RCA label in SACD is something to hear and enjoy. When I compare this to that recording of the Il Trovatore I'd definitely choose the RCA SACD "Living Stereo" version. She is so lively (well she is 32 there)and full of energy and musicality. I wish there were a full recording of the whole opera by her with Arturo Basile. I would snap it without hesitation. The recording quality here is not that good as well. The RCA SACD version is in Stereo and in spite of the 1959 recording tag it carries, it is much much better. I was not very impressed with this CD.
|
|
|
|
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Amazon Home
