Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A very pleasant surprise, 24 Feb 2008
Having for years been perfectly satisfied with the famous Klemperer EMI studio recording and not feeling especially tempted to try the mono Testament set (also with Klemperer at the helm) recently released, I was particularly pleased to discover how satisfying this performance is. It's not perfect; Sciutti is a little tremulous in her aria and the great Birgit sometimes sounds a bit detached -and occasionally a little under the note in the middle section of her voice - but she really delivers in her big moments and Sciutti perks up both to blend and to contrast nicely with Nilsson in the ensembles. Nilsson also scales her voice down attractively when the emotion demands it; it's not all sand-blasting by any means. Bohme's rotund bass is almost as good as Frick's and he also has a lovely speaking voice - I can never understand it when actors are used for the dialogue; their voices almost never match the singers'. That's not the case here, as the singers speak their own dialogue and very well too. McCracken is really very affecting as Florestan; he has all the notes and sounds utterly distraught - close to madness as the result of his dreadful plight, heroic and unhinged. Krause is a little jolly-sounding as Pizarro but vocalises very attractively; minor parts are well taken by some fairly major voices. Maazel's direction isn't very subtle but it's certainly dramatic and both the orchestra and the chorus are terrific. I think that opera buffs like me who have been listening for years to - and sometimes through - ropey old mono recordings full of hiss and distortion need to remember that for many newer collectors the quality of sound is very important when one is getting to know a central work like "Fidelio", and certainly this 1964 set will not disappoint in its clarity, space and dynamics; it has been beautifully re-mastered. The artificial echo effect devised for the dungeon scene was controversial but I think it works and it is certainly consistent with the overall emphasis upon a dramatic, pacy, theatrical atmosphere. And when all is said and done, the two principals are really involved and involving. I don't say that this set is preferable to the EMI with the incomparable Ludwig and Vickers but it's a credible option.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
This Recording Is "Tops" for Vocal Power Allied with Intent Theatricality of the Singing and of Maazel's Superb Conducting, 20 Jun 2009
Many critics, and the listeners whom they influence, downgrade the worth of this supremely exciting recording of Beethoven's "Fidelio" (in the usual final version of the score). Well, they are wrong! It is true that Otto Klemperer's recording is very beautiful, and it features the incomparable Jon Vickers as Florestan among the well cast soloists, but even Klemperer's recording reeks too much of the overly-devout, oratorio-like quality of far too many performances (whether recorded in the studio or in the theatre) of this work. "Fidelio" is an OPERA (even if there is some spoken dialogue), a real music drama, NOT an oratorio or cantata! Ralph Moore's more detailed comments in another Amazon review are quite pertinent regarding the quality of the singing and this performance's stunning theatricality.
Loren Maazel really digs into the music, driving the music forward relentlessly to thrillingly theatrical effect! There is no doubting, under Maazel's baton, that indeed this is a stage work, one as fervently dramatic as any in the standard repertoire. Bergit Nilsson's voice, singing Leonore, rings out with blazingly heroic impact; she is heard in some live recordings of "Fidelio", under other conductors' direction, interpreting her part at higher levels of histrionic intensity than in this studio recording under Maazel's direction, but most buyers will prefer Maazel's excitingly conducted recording with her in the role in stereo sound that so vividly has more sonic "presence". Her partner, tenor James McCracken, in subsequent recordings that he made seldom sounded as good as he does here; as Florestan he powerfully rises to the considerable challenge of partnering a soprano of so clarion a voice as Nilsson.
Yes, Klemperer, and some other conductors too, have shaped the score's orchestral detail more exquisitely, but nearly always in musical performance contexts that vitiate the dramatic impact which Beethoven surely intended. Maazel, on the other hand, while perhaps at times driving rough-shod over some minutiae of orchestsral detail (at least compared to "Dr. Klemps"), ignites the thrilling drama that so imbues this great music. Okay, get the Klemperer recording too (which has many beauties and is sung by a superb cast of vocal soloists), but buy Maazel's recording first!
|
|
|
|