Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A reply to Daniel Deronda, 17 May 2001
By A Customer
Amy Levy's short novel explores a Jewish community in London in the 1880's. It has been called a reply to George Eliot's "Daniel Deronda" which portrayed a very romantic view of Jewish society. Levy is much harsher, more satirical in her portraits of the famillies in her novel. Reuben Sachs is a young man who, in his mother's words, "will do nothing rash". He is destined for a brilliant political career, but he needs to marry money to support his ambitions, and he is unfortunately in love with Judith Quixano, who is beautiful but poor. Judith loves Reuben, but their love is undeclared, although both their famillies gossip about them. As well as satirising the vulgarity and snobbishness of her community, Levy also makes a plea to change the aimless lives of young women who can have no career but marriage. This, of course, wasn't restricted to Jewish girls of the period. Judith is intelligent, but she relies on Reuben for books and conversation about politics. She lives with a family who spends any amount on material possessions, but sees money spent on books as wasted. Judith's fate is unsurprising, but the journey we take with her is fascinating. Amy Levy died young (she committed suicide at the age of 27), otherwise we might have more novels of this quality on the Jewish experience in Britain.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting discovery from Persephone, 7 April 2007
Reuben Sachs is the love affair between Reuben Sachs and his "cousin", Judith Quinxano, in London in the late 19th century. At the time that it was written it was an exploration of the contemporary mores in Jewish, upper middle class society.
In some ways it covers the same ground that Jane Austen had earlier: the inferior position of women in society; their lack of opportunities for education or a career; the necessity of marriage; and the importance of a dowry as a cash injection for a young man.
More than that, it is an exploration of both the positive and (more often) negative aspects of the close, sometimes claustrophobic, Jewish set at the time.
To modern readers, Levy's descriptions of the Eastern appearance, sallow skin, gaudiness of dress, and focus on materialism, sound anti-Semitic, so it was interesting to read that the novel was received as such at the time. But there is more to her book than that. Whilst railing against the insular nature of her society, she also recognises its strengths and attractions.
The book is set over a comparatively short period of time, a clever construction which allows her to impart a vivid description of life as it was at the time, without losing narrative drive.
Julia Neuberger's preface is helpful in setting the scene into its historical context, although she restrains from a literary critique.
An interesting read.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable surprise, 24 April 2009
This is my second favourite Persephone book so far after 'Miss Pettigrew'. Amy Levy was called the 'Jewish Jane Austen' for a reason. This book is full of domestic detail, and the plot, although slight, is there, and the book has a surprising but satisfactory ending.
|
|
|
|