Raghnall Macille Dhuibh, in "The Scotsman"
"Tha e furasta ge-ta taobhan a ghabhail nuair thigear gu cogaidhean an ama sin, agus tha e cudromach a bhith a' cuimhneachadh nach robh an t-urram agus am fulang uile air aon taobh na sgeulachd. Aon rud luachmhor tha Byrne a' toirt dhuinn se leabhar-latha an Urr. John Weir, a ghabhadh 'na phriosanach aig Alastair mac Colla 's a dh'eug fo smachd.
Tha eilean Cholbhasa aig teas meadhain sgeul Cholla Chiotaich, agus tha e air feumail gur ann an Colbhasa tha an t-ughdar a' fuireach. Cha leig mi ach aon ghnust mun leabhar: rinn Byrne feum mor de phaipear "Colla Ciotach", le fear Ronald Black ... ach dhiochuimhnich e sin innse dhan luchd-leughaidh" -
The Ileach
"... a book that sends the interested reader scurrying to other books to follow up leads that he has laid. ... it is years since I read an history book which so encouraged me to follow up so many references, as a good history book should.... The book is well produced and well organised, with a good summary of the contents of each chapter so that you do not need to search too far to find what the author has to say on a particular event or personality. It is well provided with maps, genealogical tables and appendices as well as a bibliography. It is a substantial contribution to the historiography of Argyll and of the great political and religious struggles of the seventeenth century. No household in Islay, Jura or Colonsay should be without it."
See all Product Description