|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent work on neglected contribution to war effort, 11 Jul 2000
By A Customer
This book deals with the contribution made by the Indian Corps in the early battles of the Western Front and a remarkable story it is too.The sepoys were put into the front line the moment they arrived, often issued with rifles they had no experience of handling before, facing, for the first time, artillery and, later, gas. They did remarkably well, plugging up the gaps in the First Battle of Ypres and counter-attacking with gusto at Neuve Chappelle. This book is particuarly strong on how the Indian troops - totally ill-prepared for high intensity warfare - dealt with the Western Fornt on an individual and cultural level. Extensive, and effective, use of letters and diaries from the Indian troops themselves is used throughout. The author, formerly an officer in the Ghurkas, clearly has a great empathy with his subject and his contemptous dismissal of one oft-quoted source which, completely wrongly, has Indian troops cowering under fire shows his completely understandable, partisan leanings. The book is the better for it. My quibbles (minor, I'm a pedant)is that the descriptions of combat can read more like a military report than a narrative and without a decent grasp of the battles of late 1914 and early 1915, you might wonder quite why it all matters so much, but the sweep of the book overcomes these minor failings. I would recommend anyone with an interest in World War One, or the Indian Army, to buy this book and read a truly fascinating, and neglected, story of a war that has attracted so much attention.
|