Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
176 of 197 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Gargoyle, 28 Jan 2009
After the slight disappointment earlier this year from Nick Harkaway's debut novel The Gone-Away World, I was a little skeptical about reading another new writer because I often find too many flaws ridden throughout the pages. However, The Gargoyle is another case entirely. In fact, the book is so well told that I just can't find a single fault. It really is quite possibly the most "perfect" of books I've ever read - and I'm not one to lavish praise on just anything. It's so rare that I will read and not try to change sections for my own personal endeavor, but reading The Gargoyle was refreshing - a strange word to use perhaps considering Davidson's knack for graphic description, particularly on his delineation of how the human body burns. It was refreshing because it was original, and even now a week after reading I am finding it hard to start another book because I am still emotionally involved with The Gargoyle. Our nameless narrator happens upon a vision while being high on drugs and booze where a swarm of burning arrows are heading towards his car as he drives along the cliff edge. He crashes down the gauge and eventually catches fire, leaving him a monster but alive albeit in the care of the burn ward at the hospital.
The story entails the once beautiful man during his hospital rehabilitation after the incredible survival of the burning wreck. Along the way he meets Marianne Engel - a woman who he initially believes to have come from the psychiatric ward. She is a carver of Gargoyles, tattooed, eccentric and scraggy and she comes to visit regularly telling him stories of long ago, from ancient Japan to medieval Germany, Italy and the vikings of Iceland. She also claims that the two of them were lovers in the 1300s - her being a nun at Engalthal Monastery and him a warrior wounded from battle (no wonder he thought she was crazy). As our narrator is brought back to life by his newly found friends at the hospital he is also brought to love and so his story goes much deeper than the tales he "believes" to have been weaved.
I've tried not to give too much away, so that you can read it for yourself because you really must. A truly remarkable piece of work; ambitious and taunting, yet so beautifully told. If you don't believe in love now you will after this, and you might even get the urge to buy a gargoyle... though I doubt it. A modern masterpiece.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not my cup of tea, 15 Aug 2009
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
I'll be honest - this book has been staring at me from my shelves for some time like a... well, a gargoyle! I am a fan of fantasy fiction - not an expert on the topic for sure but I've read enough to know the genre quite well. This book belongs in the "romantic" branch - it's no Lord of the Rings or David Gemmel, and certainly not in your Terry Pratchett section either. The book, like much good fantasy, deals with real issues (in this case the meaning of love, and life - you know, nothing heavy) within a distinctly fantastic situation. There's a sense of mystery to the novel (who's the narrator? Are the characters real or imaginary? Are they mad or telling the truth?) and much of the book is episodic with little stories that take you outside the main plot but still contribute something to it.
I think, looking at the other reviews, that I'm the odd one out here, as everyone else seems to have given it five stars, so I feel a little guilty, or that I've missed something important.
I don't think The Gargoyle is like other genre novels where a new one in a series comes out and everyone who reads it loves it and ignores its obvious flaws. So I'm not thinking that there's a certain reality-distortion field here and instead I do genuinely believe that the book isn't aimed at people like me. It's not a bad book, it's just that I didn't really enjoy it. However, having said that, it's one of those books that, while I wouldn't wholeheartedly recommend to a friend ("I know you'll like this") I would suggest to them ("You might like this, you might not, but I'd be interested to know what you think"). And in some ways, that's the better kind of book because you know you'll end up having a conversation about it.
Maybe three stars is a little mean...
|
|
|
58 of 67 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A strong debut, 23 Oct 2008
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
This was a well written debut novel from a talented writer.
The interesting device of never revealing the identity of the narrator is a quirky plot point.
The Gargoyle of the title is the narrator, a handsome young man who while driving stoned and drunk one night crashes his car into a ravine and is burned in the resulting fire. He finally awakens in a burns unit to find his body has been ravaged by the flames and he has entered his own version of hell. It is during this period that he meets Marianne Engel, a renowned sculptor who stuns him by suddenly annoucing they were lovers seven hundred years ago in Germany and she has been searching for him since then.
The narrator is sure that Marianne is delusional and the fact that at their first meeting she is actually a patient in the physicatric ward does support that but after her release she continues to visit him and their relationship grows.
It is during these time that she begins to tell him the story of their first meeting and also occasionally seems to throw in seemingly random other stories as well. Even after his release from the unit when he goes to live with her the stories continue until finally they all come together and they both complete the journeys they have been on him to self redemption and her to final peace.
The author has chosen a large subject to tackle for his first novel, the question of what is love and how it endures and what one is prepared to do for it, mixed in with self realization and redemption, can one persons love be so strong as to drive them on through endless lifetimes for seven hundred years searhing for the one they lost?
Was this the best book I have ever read? Well no. Will it change my life for having read it? Again no. Is it a well written absorbing read with well drawn characters? Yes. Would I recommend it? A definite yes.
The measure of an author for me is whether they have engaged me enough to want to read other work by them and I can say that Andrew Davidson has done that with the Gargoyle.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Beatrice Colin
by David Ebershoff
by Steven Galloway
by Jesse Kellerman
