Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
47 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic!, 21 Aug 2006
Where do you start with a book like this? Maybe with Alister Pearson's eye-catching front cover painting of the 10th Doctor and Rose (worth the £7.99 alone). It has 7 stories written by the finest Doctor Who writers around. It has illustrations that bring an already fantastic set of stories to life And to top it off, it can all be yours for under a tenner! (Thats Ten Pounds to our overseas cousins).
Mark Gatiss's 'Cuckoos Spit', is written in the style of a diary entry. An imaginative and experimental style that works so well for the story. It's dark, eery and gripping with some great one-liners. Daryl Joyce's illustrations accompany the story and help add to the eerie-ness.
Gareth Robert's 'The Cat Came Back', could easily be made into a TV adventure with so many strands of classic who, and some great continuity thrown in for good measure. Illustrated by Martin Geraghty, whose work weaves nicely into the story, with poignant moments brought to life with his illustrative genius.
Tom MacRae's offering, is 'Once upon a Time', which right from the get-go, draws you into the storyline, in a warm "Mr Kipling" manner. Viewers of 'Rise of the Cybermen' / 'The Age of Steel' will be surprised at how different this story and its style is. Such is MacRae's talent, that you are left wanting to know what his next Doctor Who project could be with great excitement. Illustrations are by Adrian Salmon, who's amazing linear style, compliments it perfectly.
Justin Richard's story is 'Gravestone House', full of mystery and intrigue. The bit in the graveyard was chilling and very classic who! Andy Walker provides the illustrations, adding dramatic visualisation to the story in your minds eye.
Robert Shearman's story is the intriguingly titled 'Untitled'. Here, Shearman captures the relationship and dialogue between The 10th Doctor and Rose, perfectly. The story itself is typical of Shearman's work, it consists of a tight, well-paced and imaginative storyline, that will make you think twice before going to an art gallery ever again. Illustrations are by Brian Williamson, who uses focus to really bring the subjects to life.
Next up is Nicholas Briggs's story 'No One Died', which starts off with a very tongue-in-cheek nod to some 1960's (off air) Doctor Who history. A mystery, is the current that runs through this story, and one that keeps your interest from the beginning. Briggs obviously paid attention to the Poirot's and Miss Marple's of yester-year, as his ability to tell this particular mystery was faultless. One wishes Briggs was around in the Tom Baker era, as the story would have also fitted nicely as a 4th Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith adventure. Illustrations were by Ben Wilsher, whose work is a fine accompanyment that could easily translate to an animated version of the story. BBC - if you are listening - make this a WebCast please!
Finally we have Steven Moffat's 'Corner of the Eye', which is very cleverly written in the style of an instant message conversation. Without giving too much away, its quite a dark story, with an almost sombre tone that makes you think about it for a good while after reading it. The end is quite creepy, and leaves you looking over your shoulder. Brilliant! Daryl Joyce captures the dark, shadowy feel of the story with intelligence and sheer talent. Moffat is a genius!
There is also a comic strip called 'Opera of Doom' written by Jonathan Morris, and pencil art by Martin Geraghty. Its perfectly situated in the middle of the book, as a breather between stories. The story itself is set in Venice, and has a great would-be, pre-titles sequence.
Overall, you will notice an overly positive review of the book, but thats because the book, in simple terms, is utterly brilliant! It's wonderfully presented, from the front cover to the back page, and is full of treats that every Doctor Who fan will enjoy. Kudos to Clayton Hickman who's DWM experience is brought to use in the editing of this masterpiece.
Why only 5 stars Amazon? This deserves a 10!
|
|
|
27 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Spectacular Book!, 15 Aug 2006
All I can say is wow - as season two draws to a close the magical adventures of the Doctor and Rose continue through these spectacularly told stories. Eight seperate stories each with fantastic drawings that aid the story and bring the imagination to life, these are classic stories showing how the Doctor and Rose live on together. A brilliant book for all ages, appreciated by everyone of any age. This is unmissable for any fan, and come with a letter from the Doctor himself at the beginning! A must buy for any Doctor Who fan!
|
|
|
16 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic! As good as the 70s Annuals!, 26 Oct 2006
I loved this 'storybook', it reminded me of the old 70s/80s Tom Baker/Peter Davidson annuals I had as a Who-obsessed eight year-old (in the mid 80s), all great stories with spooky if random artwork. Amazingly, in an annual the prose stories are actually good, and the comic strip is the weakest thing on offer! Great fun.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Gareth Roberts
by Keith Temple
by BBC
by Various
by Gareth Roberts
