Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Welcome to the Wild Side, 6 Jul 2005
By A Customer
Utterly unpatronising, dense and fiery language, parents who make the Wicked Witch of the West look like Mary Poppins, feral boy and feral dog, legend and fantasy, dream and nightmare, and are we dealing with terminal illness or a cocktail of schizophrenias? One of those truly searching 'cross-overs' of adult and children's fiction. On one level a rite of passage, on another a playing out of adolescent rage, revenge and fear in a world more or less closed to adults. Ranks with - and this is meant to be the highest praise - Robert Cormier at his very best.
|
|
|
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Genuinely striking writing, 25 May 2006
This is a very dark book, and not one that fits easily into the genre of children's, or at least young people's writing. The story of two boys, bound by blood into the eternal tussle of good and evil, which reduces a town to ashes and forces the reader to rationalise murder, is not easily digested. Nor is the structure of the narrative by any means simplistic: Hartnett carefully controls what is revealed to the reader with the skill of a true thriller writer.
That said, what sets this book apart from many others in its bracket it not the story, but the writing. Hartnett's unashamed exploitation of the fullest range of English's potential for rich and poetic meaning is consistently challenging and always hugely rewarding. The atmosphere of the book is unrelentingly close, even to the point of causing beads of sweat to break out in sympathy with the inhabitants of the awful, sweltering dustbowl of Mulyan, the town in which the novel is set.
This novel is by no means a lightweight read for the beach, but for older teenagers and adults alike it offers a prose experience in a class of its own.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing , read after read, 29 Jun 2009
I first read this book from a library. now I have a strange way of reading , sort of the same way I eat my food....If I like a book I will read it slowly, beause I just dont want it to end. Now this happens VERY VERY rarly.
but this is the sort of book you dont want to put down, but have to in order to let the feeling stay. a little on corny side #i know, but its th etruth. I decided to have my copy so I purchased, I even highlighed 4 quotes from the book i love 'MERCHENT OF DETRESS' was one of my favourite lines. The author does start out slowy, but 10 pages in I was hooked.Thats what I love about this book, so many good messeges despite the haunting finish.
if you keep at something long enough, the end result is always worthwile, in this case; only 10 pages of uninterest; but after this you will be hooked .
P>S
like most, I wasnt actually aware it was a hcildrens book, it was in my college library so thats why I didnt know!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|