Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another Kind of Terror, 15 April 2007
Richard Flanagan's new novel (released in Australia in December 2006) is about terrorism. Not the kind that involves suicide bombings and religious fervour; the kind that involves mass paranoia and the abuse of power. The second kind is the more insidious.
The unknown terrorist of the title is Gina Davies, a young woman from the suburbs, pretty much alone in the world and focused entirely on achieving material dreams. She's a stripper and pole dancer, a pill-popper and, on the whole, rather a shallow person. Not the kind of character you'd normally feel for as a reader. Yet Flanagan succeeds in making us sympathise with her completely, to feel outrage and pity for the monumental injustice she suffers at the hands of the authorities, the media and the society she inhabits.
A chance encounter and a one-night stand with a suspected terrorist (who, as it turns out, probably isn't a terrorist after all) transforms the rather naive Gina into public enemy number one. Frightened, confused and mistrustful of authority, she becomes a fugitive. Fuelled by hysterical media coverage, Gina is hunted down as a dangerous home-grown terrorist. The ending is not happy.
Certainly, The Unknown Terrorist is emotionally gripping. As we follow Gina's mental and physical unravelling, it's very hard to remain detached. It's hard because it's all so absurd. Surely no sane society could put two and two together and get five in such a disastrous, unjust way.
Of course, it's a highly political novel, and as such, its purpose is to arouse, to question, to jolt. It succeeds handsomely in this regard. It's also guilty of being melodramatic at times, and some strands of the storyline are a little too contrived. However, judging a political novel purely on its technical merit would be to miss the point completely. Flanagan has set out to make a powerful statement and has succeeded.
I hope lots of people read it and talk about it. I hope someone makes a film of it. It's not an uplifting book by any means - it's pessimistic and downright depressing, in fact. But it's an important book for our times, such as they are.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thrilling, stunning story in the aftermath of 9/11, 14 Aug 2008
"The Unknown Terrorist" is Richard Flanagan's so far best book, I would say. It is so far also the only book I have read, which manages to convey a real point in the aftermath of 9/11, without working superficial tears or shallow points. His point here is to show how manipulative media and politics are, how easy people are manipulated, how little someone's rights count and how easy it is to misuse well-staged mass hysteria for personal benefit.
The main hero of this book is the pole (or lap-) dancer Gina Davies, shortly called "The Doll" throughout this book. The Doll's main interest is making enough money by stripping and dancing at the "Chairman's Lounge", in order to change her life. Her biggest mistake is not the one-night stand she has with Tariq, but the rejection of Richard Cody, the media star. When three bombs are found in backpacks, Tariq is far too quickly and easily identified by media as the wanted terrorist. Footage from the supervisory-cams of Tariqs appartment building showing him with Gina, gives Richard Cody the chance to identify Gina and to misuse her for personal advantage as "The Unknown Terrorist". I will not reveal more of the story here.
Richard Flanagans writing is brilliant (even superior to his "Death of a River Guide"), he never lost my attention at any moment. A thrilling book, great literature, beating any thriller by it's writing and it's message, which leaves you stunned and with the shocking thought, that by virtue of some coincidence, this could happen to each and every single one of us. A book, which pleads for understanding rather than prejudice.
One of my personal books of the year!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
8 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
awful!, 7 Feb 2008
This book was one of the worst books I have ever wasted my time reading. I preserved to the end, encouraged by the glowing reviews (what were these critics being paid?!), but there was no redeeming twist or revelation. Firstly, the plot is totally unbelievable, even in this day and age of over-paranoid terror laws. I mean, a drug-taking, promiscuous lap dancer with being mistaken for an Islamic terrorist because she happened to sleep with a drug trafficker (also mistaken for an Islamic terrorist). Secondly, even if the plot was believable, the main character, The Doll, is so thinly constructed and shallow I found it hard to care what happened to her, let alone feel any sympathy. Clunky prose, careless inaccuracies and pointless plot diversions abound. The Unknown Terrorist left me thinking that maybe the Da Vinci Code wasn't that after all.
Don't let the Nietzsche stuff in the prelude, nor the dedication to Guantanamo inmate David Hicks lead to believe that this is a deep, tense thriller. It is a poor example of run-of-the mill genre fiction. It probably only got published because illegal detention is in fashion at the moment. Campaign to get Guantanamo shut down so more books like this don't litter our shelves!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|