The Quest for the Celtic Key (Paperback)

I am enjoying the journey the authors have started me on by introducing Scottish History in a way that is most importantly for me, easy to understand! The book is written in a manner that allows you to not have to read it from cover to cover, but lets you browse any of the topics at any time.

I have learned a huge amount about peoples and religions I never even new existed and have learnt that a lot you hear about groups like Freemasons isn't always true!! I'm looking forward to finding out more about the Grail Myths and Legends too - could have something to do with my name!

It's a great read!

But when this is done here, the sources do check out and often end up being from more conventional sources, but had not---for whatever reason(s)---been used in the past, perhaps because Scottish history has often been written by those other than Scots. But including such topics now and then ---which are true facts in the Scottish historical record, albeit lesser known -- really adds a fascinating dimension to the whole work and in doing so, the authors show great respect for the reader, too.

That the authors had the courage to even attempt this work says something, but it is a rare opportunity indeed to get "the whole story" from one book---but this book is really more of a compendium of separate chapters, all dealing with a different aspect of Scottish history, each of which could well stand on their own. The authors do not make any sensational claims nor do they state that each chapter is all there is to say on a particular subject.

But as a whole, this book offers the reader---beginner or expert--- a readable, carefully researched work, with detailed notes and an extensive Bibliography and an index with many cross-references. It covers the usual Scottish history subjects quite dutifully, but the chapter on Rosslyn Chapel is particularily outstanding as well as the intriguing information on the Guild and masonic traditions of Scotland. Sure beats the 'usual stereotypes' about Scotland. Highly recommended!

Indeed the range of information gives the impression of being a little jumbled without a clear thread bringing it together. One theme which does run through the book is wholly unsatisfactory: ¡°. . .perhaps it (accuracy) does not ultimately matter. . . Fact or fiction, the effect remains.¡± Similarly: ¡°The emphasis is on the tradition, not the reality¡±. Amongst other shortcomings is a woefully inadequate index (e.g. ogham, mentioned in the text is omitted form the index).

But in the wealth of fascinating detail of this book you can obtain the fruits of recent research (such as Seahenge) and learn rarely quoted information about Newton, Blake, Churchhill and many others. Mind you, with the emphasis on the tradition rather than the reality, can you trust it?