|
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Physics Revision Guide not nearly as good as it could be..., 24 Jun 2002
After using CGP's Physics revision book and for other subjects as well, I can't say that they've made a lot of difference to my grade. The Physics book does contain a lot of information - enough to get you an A*. However, sometimes you get the feeling that they've given you too much information. For the Double Award, you don't need to go into too much depth for each topic. On top of this is the fact that it usually takes over half a page to make a simple point. It's all written in the style that people have weeks to revise Physics and not nine other GCSEs to prepare for. I found it impossible to use for last-minute revision. The book is reasonably well presented. Each page relates to an individual topic, and there's plenty of sub-headings to divide it up. The cheerful illustrations help you to relate each bit of theory to a real-life situation, although some are more confusing than helpful. At the bottom of each page is a box containing important points or revision tips. However, more-often-than-not, this ends up being patronising or repeating the same point time-and-time-again (the only tip they seem to be able to give is to write mini-essays). A major problem is that each page looks the same. Little imagination has been put into each one. Going through page-after-page presented in the same monotonous way is frankly depressing. At the end of each chapter are questions which are useful to find the gaps in your revision. There is some good advise too, like a page on formulae and formulae triangles. One thing I found annoying was the fact that, apart from a few hastily done page references at the beginning, it's difficult to know which pages relate to which syllabus. It's easy to revise something which you don't have to - a complete waste of time. Perhaps they should have symbols that relate to each syllabus on the top of each page? Whether you find this book, and all other CGP books, useful really depends on how you revise best. If you can assimilate facts really easily and quickly, the series' shortcomings won't be a problem to you. If you don't, you will struggle, and your revision will become worse. All in all, CGP have made a bit of a meal of producing a revision book, which shouldn't be a difficult task, as shown by other publishers. The series' main redeeming feature is the fact that nowhere are they expensive, but I would prefer to pay a little bit more for extra quality.
|