Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, 1 Oct 2002
Always looking forwards to a new book of Hellblazer, this was a major disappointment. It has little to do with the John Constantine we know and love from Moore, DeLano or Ellis, and the storyline lacks the usual wit and flaire of the man who gives the devil the finger. Even more disappointing is it that this was written and drawn by the people behind that excellent serie 100 Bullets.
|
|
|
3 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A contrasting opinion on this book, 22 Feb 2005
By A Customer
It is difficult to know how to grade this graphic novel because it reprints a story arc of six issues of the monthly Hellblazer comic, which in itself was the second part of a much longer sequence recounting John Constantine's adventures travelling across the United States following the death of a friend. Do I grade it in the context of the entire US-set storyline (all of which has been reprinted in, I think, four volumes) or do I assess it independently? I have rated it not on the entire run, not even on everything that is reprinted in this volume but on the strength of just one of the chapters of the story, for reasons of which I will come to. The John Constantine in the United States storyline immediately attracted its critics on its release because it was, I think, the first time that a non-Brit, Brian Azzarello, was trusted with the writing chores. But anyone who has read, "Hard Time", the volume which immediately precedes this, also by Azzarello and comics great Richard Corben will have no doubt that the characterisation of Constantine is as good as anything concocted by a Brit. Perhaps this US-spin on the title can be re-viewed in the light of the new Constantine movie which has, as of this writing, only just been released in the States, and "threatens" a totally Americanised version of the character. You will not totally understand all of "Good Intentions" unless you have read "Hard Time" but you need go no further back. I too was put off by Constantine's extended family of supporting characters prior to this storyline but this proved to be the perfect jumping-on point for new readers who know nothing more about the character other than that he is a modern-day mage with a checkered past and shady morals. This volume takes elements of "Deliverance", "Moby Dick", "The Wicker Man" and "sex, lies and videotape" and mixes them together in a comic-book equivalent of a road movie (a road comic?) in a way that crystallises not only what John Constantine is "about" but what a Brit might think backwoods USA is like, and still manages to be haunting, gripping and original. However, the aspect of the book which earns it the five stars I have awarded it is the first chapter which I have read many times because I think it a masterwork which warrants multiple readings, and is alone worth the cost of the book; at least I think so. Judging by the difficulty in obtaining the original single issue which contains that chapter in the back issue market, it would appear that even though it does not command ludicrously extortionate prices, its artistic merit is recognised and sought after. The art is produced by Marcelo Frusin, who, whilst no Richard Corben, more than holds his own in this volume, and it could even be said that this paperback represents his best work on the title before the punishing monthly schedule forced him to "simplify" his work. The first chapter of this volume is one of those stories which can be read as a standalone piece and is also one of those examples of a perfect comic, from the exquisitely judged chiarascuric art to the atmospheric colouring and especially to the darkly funny, manipulative and sometimes subtly understated dialogue uttered by Constantine. The remaining five chapters in the volume are not as good - how could they be - but they too have their moments and comparing the ending of the first chapter with that of the sixth which both show Constantine coming to the rescue definitely adds to the total effect. I am by no-means a die-hard Hellblazer fan and cannot claim to have read more than a handful of issues before Azzarello came on board so cannot claim to be an expert on all things Constantine but "Hard Time" and "Good Intentions" are excellent additions to anyone's comic collection.
|
|
|
|