Hands-on Photoshop 4 for Macintosh and Windows [Illustrated] (Paperback)

And, now that I have finished the whole book, I really have no idea what the complaints are about. All the lessons on the CD are functional, so check your operating systems, people, or maybe, be a little more careful following through with the procedure in the lessons. There are some spelling errors. So what? The content is sound. I found no major errors like non-functional scripts or missing files. The chapter lesson for Actions DOES work. All the lessons work. I think the problem may be that anyone who uses this book still needs to utilize some critical thinking skills and some experimentation to get through the complexity of the software program itself -- the book cannot be blamed for the intrinsic complexity and redundant functions of Photoshop.

My final opinion is that this Andres book was actually "FUN" to use. It even made Photoshop fun to use -- and that is an achievement. I'm actually going to do the lessons on Layers and Masking over again for just pure enjoyment, because now I now feel comfortable using basic functions of Photoshop and I don't feel afraid of it anymore! **** for this one, Baby.

I didn't find any problems using the Layers lesson as one reviewer described below; the lesson was pretty straightforward, I thought -- perhaps it was a memory allocation problem or a platform problem (I used it on Win98 with 64 Megs driven by PII400) -- who knows. I haven't tried the chapter on Actions yet, but I will post a follow-up.

There ARE errors in the book and I think on the disc but they amount to minor typos. I haven't come across any mislabelled files, yet. Here and there the author confused me when he referred to layers being on top or below, and he meant the stratification on the palette and not in the image itself -- I figured it out (hooray for me). So, the book isn't Perfection, but what I find attractive and useful about it is the author's style of instruction, which in general is easy to understand, not overly technical. Also good are the pace, the ready-made CD examples. He presented the subject directly and matter-of-factly without much digression, which I like. I tend not to like the extremely regimented and hyperformal tone of most of the Adobe Classroom in a Book editions -- those books have no typos or file errors but because of their minutiae, they induce sleep; I fell out of my chair frequently and injured myself, which required that I stop using them. They sit perfectly on my shelf, though. This Andres book isn't as detailed as the Adobe books, but you also don't get bogged down in extreme detail. It got me through Photoshop's ridiculously complex interface so I could experiment on my own -- which I think is how you learn programs like Photoshop, right?

Anyway, Roger, I give this book a Thumbs Up for friendly style, speed, ease of use, and fun examples.

For someone with basic knowledge of PhotoShop, this might be a reasonable text, but I would not recommend it for the beginner!