Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The futility of war, 26 Feb 2001
This novel begins as a gentle satire on the young people of the pre WWI period. The women are obsessed with getting the vote, the men involved in Social Reform. William and Griselda are typical young people of the period, self-absorbed yet trying to make the world a better place. They meet, fall in love, marry, and go to Belgium for their honeymoon. But, it is 1914, and they emerge from their idyll into a world at war, a world which they cannot recognise. All their interest in social conditions hasn't alerted them to the fact that Europe was moving towards war, and they are as bewildered as if they had been transported to another planet. This is the point at which the novel changes from a light satire to something far more profound and moving. William's gradual realisation of what has happened and his response to his new world is completely believable. This is not the war of Owen, Graves or Sassoon. Cicely Hamilton wrote the book in 1918 when her own experience of war service in France was still vivid and immediate. It won the Prix Femina in 1919 and was then unjustly forgotten until Persephone's reprint. Maybe the realism and the lack of conventional "heroism" has something to do with this. It deserves to be read and admired as a novel about the response of an ordinary young man in extraordinary circumstances.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A bitter dose of reality, 16 Jan 2006
The fascinating tale of a young man thrust from a highly sheltered existence into the 'real' world; a place of death, destruction and human cruelty - in other words: World War I. William's naive convictions, fostered by keen involvement in pacifist groups, are shattered when he and his recent wife find themselves face to face with a German firing squad while honeymooning in France. Like the other Persephone books I've read, this one deals with gut wrenching emotion in a smooth manner, that is, through a story interesting and easy to read. Hightly recommended - real insight into that time period.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Little man caught in great events, 30 Mar 2009
Cicely Hamilton wrote this book in 1918, probably writing in a khaki tent having spent the past four years in war service in France. So no wonder she writes so vividly of the emotions of war. William is an insurance clerk, a little Pooter who in the run-up to the war has taken up pacifism and radical Socialism. His bride to be Griselda is an excitable Suffragette. They are ignorant, suburban, caught up in the small-minded cut and thrust of petty political scuffles ... and at this point in the novel, Cicely Hamilton made me laugh out loud with her dry witticisms. But when the young couple spend their August 1914 honeymoon secluded, and rather bored, in the Ardennes they have no idea what is happening in the wider world. The humour of the beginning gives way to horror as this commonplace pair of young innocents are tragically caught up in the unfolding war. Fascinating.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|