|
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Old Wine in a New Bottle, 30 Dec 1998
By A Customer
Fred Bronson's knowledge of pop music is truly staggering, and his contributions to pop music reference are immeasurable; unfortunately, he has apparently shown little interest in checking up on this supposedly "revised and expanded" book. So what's wrong? About 95% of the information in the 1997 version of the book can be found in previous editions (a side-by-side comparison test with two previous editions revealed almost no changes), and what WAS updated was usually a tag paragraph (printed with obviously different type) listing details of the artist's death. Revised and expanded? By whom? Collectors, disc jockeys and devotees of pop music have referred to this book for years, and while the original information collected by Bronson was usually well researched and revealing, the old stories about songs and artists are so familiar to most music fans by now that they're pointless to include today. Many a deejay has grown tired of regaling listeners with stories that they've heard for decades, but Bronson continues to beat a dead horse, and his carelessness has cost him. Another problem is that Bronson does not have enough interesting information for certain songs: In some cases, he circumvents a particular #1 song and instead writes about something trivial, such as the frequency of repeated words in #1 song titles. Shouldn't these miscellaneous chart tidbits belong in another book? Worst of all is the lack of information about less-well-known artists, notably one-hit wonders. There are innumerable box sets and CD anthologies available today, many of which meticulously detail minutia about even long-forgotten hitmakers that appear in this book, so why hasn't Bronson checked out a few of these collections' liner notes and then vetted his own text for some serious updating? Longtime buyers of "The Billboard Book of #1 Hits" should not invest in the latest edition, since even a decade-old copy of the book will suffice for most of them. We can all only hope that Bronson will take more care in the next edition and give his readers something better than this.
|