|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Inaccurate but very motivating, 21 Sep 2000
By A Customer
If you train in or watch MMA then this is a must-buy book. It makes you feel like you are in the world of MMA and you`ll train even harder. BUT it is full of inaccuracies and half-truths that serve to exaggerate Shanmrock`s standing. Its as if being a top ten fighter is not enough, they want to make out he`s the greatest ever.Crucial facts left out include: Dan Severn was choked out by Royce Gracie (UFC4) before Ken did it; The Oleg Taktarov was actually a draw, and very competitive; In the rematch with Royce, its true that Shamrock bloodied him, but its also true that if it had gone to points Royce would have won because he was the only person trying to win. Shamrock tried nothing for 30 minutes until a single punch messed Royce`s eye; Before the book was finished, Shamrock had lots of defeats in Pancrase, including being choked out by Funaki, heel-hooked by Suzuki, knocked out by Frank Lobman in a kickboxing match. Also it glosses over the fact some Pancrase matches were `worked` (i.e. predetermined outcomes); Ken has never finished a MMA tournament - he always gets injured; Dan Severn is the only truly top class fighter in his prime that Shamrock has beaten - Kimo is 2nd tier, Dan won the rematch, Brian Johnston was not a `kickboxing champion` (he later lost to Kimo, too). Don`t be put off. Shamrock is a legitmate champion, its just that the book would have you believe he was the undisputed king of MMA or something. His achievements are actually exceeded by his brother Frank. Since the book, Ken returned to MMA in Japan`s Pride organisation this year. He knocked out the tough Alexander Otsuka and then got knocked out against the formidable Kazuyuki Fujita in a fight Ken was winning easily until he ran out of gas. I really enjoyed the book and would have given it 5 stars if not for the bias towards Ken that doe other fighters a disservice and denies the reader a full appreciation of Shamrock`s standing.
|