Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Clancy's Successor ?, 5 Sep 2003
I picked up this book as a lastminute travel companion for a long flight and so did not have any preconceived ideas about the author or the book. For fans of Tom Clancy's early work this book is as good as any in the military thriller genre that Clancy presides over, albeit rather falteringly these days. The genuinely intricate plot centres around one last, rogue, Russian Typhoon class nuclear sumbarine on a journey that could have dire consequences on the world stage, in pursuit a Los Angeles class US Navy sub commanded by squeaky clean 'zero errors' Cmmdr Vann (or is he?). The author provides a good mix of character creation, plot turns and attention to detail that I have been missing since Clancy's classic Hunt for Red October. I urge other readers who like to be immersed in the world of 'Nukes','Boomers' and underwater cat & mouse to give this book a try - you won't be dissapointed.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Ideal Summer Thriller, 6 May 2004
'Typhoon' is a superior submarine thriller, pound for pound the equal of anything similar on the market. Crammed from first page to last with twists and turns, rounded characters, excellent technical detail, and evocative descriptive prose, Robin White's debut novel (certainly as good as, if not better than, the all-time bench-mark submarine chase-thriller, 'The Hunt for Red October') is set to become a classic of the genre.The premise is simple - out on patrol in Russian waters the USS Portland strays upon what appears to be a ballistic missile launch from a Russian submarine, but soon discovers that the launch was a ruse used to distract them from a second submarine as it slipped past them into the open sea. From here, amid an escalating crisis between China and Taiwan, a game of cat and mouse begins between the Portland and the Baikal in the cold waters of the Arctic. Add to this already heady mix tensions among the crew of the US boat, a dilemma for the captain of the Russian submarine, and escalating tensions between China and Taiwan, and you have a novel which will cannot fail to hold your attention. One of the best things about 'Typhoon' is White's even-handedness in his description of the Russian and US submarine crews: neither of them are portrayed in stereotypes or cliches, and throughout 'Typhoon' there is a real sense that the people onboard the Portland and Baikal are distinctive and real. This sense of veracity is what keeps the reader turning the pages of White's thriller (his other great work about submarine warfare is a work of non-fiction called 'Hostile Waters', so it isn't surprising that he's good on the facts, the details, and the intricacies of underwater combat). At every stage White succeeds in bringing the world of submarine warfare to life, whether in the depiction of petty on board squabbles between male crew-members and the unwelcome female Russian expert, or in the ratcheting-up of hard-edged tension as a potentially-fatal conflict develops between two killer submarines in the ice-cold Arctic ocean. The ideal summer read, 'Typhoon' is a novel which you can completely become completely absorded by, never once leaving the dark, dangerous world in which White tells his story.
|
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining, but unoriginal, 16 Oct 2005
Submarine novel enthusiasts will enjoy this novel, however, I had some difficulty with the originality. The cat-and-mouse games between the US and Russian submarines were very well handled in TYPHOON, since I found the technical details were nicely dealt with (I tend to get a bit bogged down with them in a Clancy). However, it also was far too reminiscent of THE HUNT FOR RED OCTOBER. Similarly, the disagreement between captain and crew was a little too reminiscent of CRIMSON TIDE. Hence the three-star rating. On the up-side, the under-ice chase was very exciting, and White's portrayal of the crews from the two nations, often at odds with one another, was really nice. Clancy tends to over-dramatise and sterotype the opposition, while Patrick Robinson's stereotypical, racist caricatures of Russian, Chinese and middle-eastern submarine crews totally ruin his novels. White did quite a nice job with the Russian crews, I felt. I also felt that the book could have done without the lead female role. Bringing this female language specialist into the story seemed totally out of place. I am still not sure what exactly it was that White was trying to achieve with her character in the story. It was a "weird" addition, rather than a "supportive" one, and the storyline would have read better without it. It is an enjoyable read though, and I took forward to more from Robin White in the future.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|