Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, 2 Oct 2007
C.S. Lewis, author of THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA, once wrote that there are three ways of writing for children. The first is to cater to what children want (but people seldom know what they want and this usually ends badly), the second develops from a story told to a specific child (Lewis Carrol's THE ADVENTURES OF ALICE IN WONDERLAND, for instance), and the third is that it is simply the best art form to convey the story.
Gemma Malley's debut young adult novel, THE DECLARATION, is of the last category.
I am making this point because while THE DECLARATION involves two teenagers, fourteen-year-old Anna and fifteen-year-old Peter, it never feels aimed towards the teen audience Therefore it is categorized as a young adult novel by the age of its narrators rather than its content and this, I believe, will give it an enduring quality. C. S. Lewis wrote, "Where the children's story is simply the right form for what the author has to say, then of course readers who want to hear that will read the story or reread it at any age."
THE DECLARATION opens in the year 2140, and people have conquered death in the form of Longevity drugs. With limited food and fuel resources, waste has become a serious crime and the worst crime of all is having a child. Anna is one of these children. She is housed at Grange Hall where she and other Surpluses are taught that the most they can ever hope for is a harsh life of servitude to make amends for their existence.
Anna is well on her way to becoming a Valuable Asset when Peter arrives at Grange Hall. He challenges everything she has learned by arguing that people who take Longevity are the real criminals and perversions of nature, not the young. He also claims that he knows her parents and that they want her back. Peter is strange and new, but is he enough to make her risk everything to escape with him?
Unlike some novels that use characters, plot, and setting as a vehicle to drive home a message, Gemma Malley never lets the moral and ethical questions she raises detract from the actual story. The characters are well drawn and identifiable, and the language is simple and unpretentious. THE DECLARATION is not without flaws, especially the failure to explain or integrate Mrs. Pincent's involvement with the black market product Longevity+ into a major plotline, but this lends mystery and excitement for a sequel.
Even though it contains a handful of science fiction and young adult hallmarks, such as a utopia/dystopia setting, wonder drugs, and finding and defining oneself, it cannot be dismissed as merely a youthful 1984 knockoff. It is mostly a book about people, fear, and loss. Themes that are, if not always, exquisitely accessible in this age.
Five Stars and a Gold Award.
Reviewed by: Natalie Tsang
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good dystopian story, 11 Dec 2007
This is a world where humanity has found a way to expand it's lifespan, where people agree to only have children if they don't have the longevity treatment. Into this world is born Anna, she's a surplus, she is being groomed to be a servant to some of the long-lived other people.
It's interesting, it does ask some interesting questions but it occasionally skitters around some bits and pieces, it's almost as if there's a longer novel lurking within this shorter young adult offering. Worth reading and an author worth watching for.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Into the Future..., 17 April 2009
The year is 2140 and drugs have been made to stop people dying, which means that there are now too much people in the world. The ones that take the Longetivity drugs have signed the Declaration, stating that they will not have children. If children are what people want, the adults do not take the drugs and Opt Out of the Declaration. But if they have had children and are taking longevtivity, the children are deemed Surpuses and are put into Surplus Halls.
Anna is a Surplus in Grange Hall, one of the most formidable Surplus Halls in the country. She goes along with the rules and is made a prefect, but in secret she keeps a diary of her feelings.
But when Peter comes to Grange Hall, everything changes. He questions the rules, and tells Anna he knows her parents. Anna is confused and doesn't know what to think, but soon she forms a plan of hope and escape with Peter.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Gemma Malley
by Lucy Christopher
by Gabrielle Zevin
by Gareth Thompson
by B. R. Collins
