|
3 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A sad disappointment, 18 Jun 2003
By A Customer
Hellboy is a great comic character, and if you've not read the graphic novels, go and do it now!This is the first of the Hellboy novellas I read, and it really could have been so much more. An excellent central character, rich source material, a dynamic narrative tradition, all excellent raw materials for the writer of fiction to get to grips with, but sadly the opportunity has been squandered here. If I were Mignola, I'd be very cross with this effort. My reservations about the Hellboy love-tryst aside, I think much more could have been done with Lost Army. Hellboy himself seems much more ineffectual than he does in the comics. We spend a lot of time with the eminently more vulnerable human associates of Big Red, but none of them really stand out as particularly loveable. But oh, the errors are there aplenty! What are MI5 doing in the middle of the Sahara when their remit is purely UK domestic counter-intelligence? Why does a member of the Church of England cross himself? And why, if Reagan is mentioned several times as being the White House incumbent in 1986 (the book's setting), is the British prime minister referred to as 'he'? It all goes towards undermining the overall impact of the book. I really wanted to like this one, I really did. If you're a Hellboy afficionado, and need more details on the HB universe, then get it for the sake of completeness (and the bonus Mignola illustrations). If you're looking for a good read, go get Mignola's Seeds of Destruction instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|