|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Very readable,meticulously researched, but short on analysis, 26 Aug 2003
By A Customer
Right from the start Jane Corbin grips the reader with the results of her detailed research, through vivid, but crisp language. She describes the vast intricate web al-Qaeda (Arabic for the base) has spun around the world, bringing the potentially dry facts to life. The book is well structured into three parts: first, the early years of al-Quaeda's formation ; the middle, and longest, most detailed section of the book covers the two years leading up to the September 11 attacks; and finally she tells us of the efforts to capture or destroy the network, and to investigate and counter the threat from al-Quaeda, together with accounts of its activities since 2001.Corbin shares with the reader her experience of interviewing a wide range of relevant people, from leaders of Gulf States, and intelligence officals to ordinary individuals caught up in attacks in East Africa or Indonesia, as well as many people whose paths have crossed those of the September 11 hijackers - those who went to school with them, took flying lessons with them or innocently rented them cars and flats. Fascinating detail and written with great storytelling skill, the book's pace matching the mounting intensity of terrorist activities during the summer of 2001. BUT I was often left wanting more, left asking why, why, why? What made bin Laden who he is? - his first twenty years are dissapointingly thinly covered in just 10 pages. Corbin tells us she used his picture as her computer screen-saver for three years. I am surprised then that she did not get "inside his head", or if she did, we are not treated to this. By the end of the book I did not feel I knew, or understood bin Laden anymore than I had at the beginning. And what of those who worked for him? What kept the lose, scattered bands of terrorists together and on their paths of destruction through all the months in the West, what did they talk about? Why did they keep going? Then, at the end of the book, there is no speculation about where bin Laden might be now. Even if no one knows, there must be some parameters, some feel for the types of environment he would look for. Perhaps it is too much to expect from a professional journalist, highly skilled at reporting what is, not what might be. But the book does describe itself as an analysis, and Corbin herself in her Preface promises us al-Qaeda's philosophy, aims and an exploration of its causes. So I was left wanting, hoping for more.
|