Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
High class swashbuckling - a superb first novel., 18 Sep 2001
This book came very highly recommended to me - and I'd always fancied giving the Norse sagas a bash - so I decided to give it a whirl.It is very ambitious in its scope and in its style; in the style of writing and dialogue Mirsky has undertaken to emulate the sagas to give his book an authentic feel - a very difficult prospect for a writer - it could go badly wrong. That Mirsky apparently pulls off this stylizing of his story is a testament to both his meticulous research and his pure writing skill. I read somewhere (I think on Amazon.com) that this very weighty first novel was the equivalent of a first-time mountaineer climbing Everest. That may be true, but that certainly doesn't mean the resulting book presents a similar challenge for the reader. The story is not dense nor bogged down by the obvious supreme knowledge of history infused into its pages. The characters aren't particularly complex, but then were norse warriors complex people? Some characters are very much larger than life, caracatures even, which you might think is at odds with the strive for realism. Not so. Historical accuracy is one thing, but the book is first and foremost a great yarn - a story packed with high seas, blood, lots of blood, implacable warriors, honour and considerable buckling of swashes. We follow the exploits of an unlikely band of mercenaries and erstwhile viking warriors setting sail from Greenland for the promised land of Vinland (North America) - a semi-mythical fertile and fruitful land of plenty bequeathed to the central character Sigtrygg. The story seemed similar to the Seven Samurai in that this band of warriors are subsequently enlisted by the native populace to tame a local warlord. But the challenges, carnage and confrontations don't end there. The storyline is elegantly simple and satisfying, as is the message of the book - that the failings of human nature will always cause people to find ways to divide themselves, take sides and, ultimately, destroy themselves.
|
|
|
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding! Breathtaking!!, 30 Dec 2002
There is a dearth of fine historical writers, and when you find one you tend to go on an on with wonderful, marvellous, outstanding. So I will trot them all out to describe this bold work of Viking lore in the tradition of Eric the Red and Lief Erickson. This is full adventure Saga set in Greenland, coastal Canada and Maine in the US, and is based in ancient Norse Myth and Lore, a period that is often neglected. It is especially interesting because it depicts "first contact" between the Norsemen and the Indians of the US. The story unfolds centring around a man, with his two feet in two separate cultures and his love for a woman from each. It is based on the little known work of Edward Reman,a Scandinavian sailor, who putting forth the idea Vinland's directions were misinterpreted and by his reckoning put it off Grand Manaan Isle, off the Maine Coast.This is a very sweeping saga, that brings to life a period that was thrilling, but alas, suffering from the lack of neglect. The Norse were one of the biggest influences in Europe, British Isles and into the US, supposedly visiting the US long before Columbus, and yet there is little done about it, so little fiction or history. So when a special gem like this comes along it's like a beacon in the darkest night. Stuart W. Mirsky has a feel for the period, and is very able to give you his vision. Highly recommend this wonderful tale!! So if you enjoyed Eaters of the Dead,and want something MORE... you will love this!! Also, I highly recommend Maggie Davis' Winter Serpent. Another excellent Viking Fiction.
|
|
|
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Original, finely-crafted, and just all-out wonderful., 16 Jan 2002
Written with a cool detachment that lends dignity to its characters, this is an epic story of Vikings and Indians (now I've seen it all). Our hero is Sigtrygg, black sheep of the family of Leif Erikson's descendants, who finds the farm that is his rightful inheritance cut from under him by his relatives. In return he is offered a ship to sail to Vinland (the good ol' USA). Even this is contested, and Sigtrygg's troubles increase exponentially as he sets out.The compelling saga is full of adventure, with a strong but unintrusive plot. Whilst the themes are operatic (Love, Death and Fate feature prominently), the narrative is stoically understated. The climax is powerful and moving, not through any special-effects gimmickry, but because of a hard-earned sense of tragic inevitability. I finished it in the small hours and went to bed sniffling and biting my quivering lip. The book itself is tragically under-exposed. If you can afford it, buy it. Full stop.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|