Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A rather short and witty book on a vast subject, 13 Oct 2009
If chronologically authored, an account or analytical narrative about economic history of the world would have taken-up many volumes. Instead, Alan Beattie, world trade Editor of the Financial Times, chose to employ his wit, knowledge and researching skills to conjure up this book comprising of short thematic chapters offering viewpoints coupled with historical contexts on anything from natural resources and agriculture to urbanisation and economic progress (or lack of it in some cases).
As for the element of surprise, Beattie is true to his word. He begins the narrative by fictionally staging the 9/11 attacks in Argentina and economic collapse of the U.S. Of course, in 2001 actual events occurred the other way round, but the author suggests it could so easily have been different. For most of the 19th century both nations held similar economic potential, yet the U.S. evolved into a superpower while Argentina went into near-terminal decline. He argues that such a trajectory was not preordained but down to differing employment of resources and political will. Both countries, he opines, were given "similar hands" at one point in history, but played them very differently.
Continuing down this path, Beattie offers a similar type of analysis about why, for instance, abundant natural resources turn out to be a curse for some nations or why religion is no hindrance to economic progress or prowess of others. Spread over ten chapters, in this short book, the auther has picked and chosen his way through history, commerce, business practices, politics and religious texts to make his arguments. Chapter 2 (on urbanisation, especially in Latin America), Chapter 3 (on trade) and Chapter 4 (on natural resources) are the ones I particularly liked.
On the other hand, one minor criticism I offer is that Beattie, at times, comes across as working needlessly overtime to live-up to the "surprising" bit in the book's title. Fictionally moving 9/11 to Argentina or opining that if the U.S. does not sort out some of its problems in the financial system, it too could head down Argentina's path is a bit over the top if not downright silly. The content of this book does not need steroid shots. However, regrettably it has escaped the author. Nonetheless, an overt eagerness to impress the reader should not be held against him.
Overall, it is a good book and by the time the reader reaches concluding pages, the author seems to have pulled ample lessons from our economic history that we ought to take note of. Rounding off with Shakespeare's words - "Our remedies oft in ourselves do lie" - is not half bad an idea, either.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Suitable for a broad audience, 11 Aug 2009
I found this book fascinating. Although, like a previous reviewer, I have no economic background and therefore couldn't comment on the soundness of the analysis, it's certainly plausible and enjoyable. The author could have written a boring book, instead it's a fascinating read with broad appeal (both myself and my father-in-law enjoyed it!). It would make a great Christmas gift for anyone interested in how the world works (or doesn't), or for those with a curious mind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
6 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
False Economy, 26 July 2009
Alan has written the background and his understanding of many of the influences and choices leading to the present worldwide economy. He has used his keen interest in history and economic training to carry out this analysis.
He starts with a comparison of today's Argentina and USA whose economies are similar at the beginning of the 20th century. He examines and argues the reasons for their present day differences. Other factors including corruption, religion and natural resources are also reviewed making the analysis in this book more comprehensive.
It is refreshing to read a book written in layman's terms presenting Alan's understanding of the reasons for "why we are where we are today". However, each sentence of the book requires concentration and occasionally a dictionary!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|