Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A good easy read, though perhaps a little light to carry the full weight of the story., 8 Aug 2006
Marina Lewycka - A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian.
This is an intriguing novel - it is not comic in the conventional sense, but perhaps the comedy is in the tragedy and vice versa. There is comedy in the real-life events, even if the light tone of the writing regrettably never matches the depth of tragedy which lies behind the tale.
The story is narrated by Nadia, the grown-up daughter of Ukrainian parents now living in England. Nadia's octogenarian father, Nikolai, falls `in love' with a Ukrainian woman, Valentina, whose blonde hair and enhanced breasts mark her out as a stereotype of cardboard cut-out precision. She clearly has no true love for Nikolai, but simply wishes for marriage, residency in Britain and money - unfortunately for her, it becomes clear that in seeing the affluent west as a solution to her problems, she too has fallen for a common stereotype. The novel's characters are revealed as Nikolai's two daughters, Nadia and Vera unite after two years' no-speaking to prevent this blonde bombshell from stealing both money and dignity from their father.
Under the surface of the book is a cast of conflicting characters jostling to find peace at each other's expense - of course, this is an equation that will never be balanced. It is Nadia in her narration who has painted the vile and voluptuous Valentina as a stereotype, although the author provides just enough information to demonstrate that there is a more tragic side to her story, even if the reader never entirely sympathises with her.
Nikolai is a more complex character; intelligent and erudite, but totally utterly lost in life. At times he is comic; at times heartbreaking. It becomes clear that he suffered greatly during the Second World War, escaped in a less-than-heroic manner and fought only for the survival of himself and his family. It is perhaps because of his gruelling life-story, or perhaps because of his erudition, that he appears more respectable to the reader; but this respect makes his continuing desperate attempts to be loved by Valentina (whom, in his playful old age, he clearly loves for her breasts and very little else) all the more tragic. When life with Valentina becomes rocky, he rather sweetly seeks stability by writing an academic book on the history of tractors (writing in his native Ukrainian).
As the story is played out, the narrator begins to discover more about her family's plight during WWII, but their involvement in this battle is similar in character to their current conflict. In family conflict, just as in war, there are no victors: each party can hope only to survive, but at great cost to themselves.
|
|
|
26 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Engrossing in many ways, 29 Dec 2006
This book has won an award for comic fiction; but, richly comic though the writing is, the story is for the most part essentially a tragic one. I am reminded of Horace Walpole's dictum, `This world is a comedy to those that think, a tragedy to those that feel.' Nikolai, an 84-year old Ukrainian-born widower who has lived in England since 1946 as an escapee from Stalinist Russia, marries a much more recent immigrant from the now independent Ukraine: Valentina, 36 years old, who is here on a visitor's visa and marries him only to be allowed permanent residence and to gain access to his money and his house. She exploits and bullies the poor and near senile old man mercilessly. His two daughters, Vera and Nadia, are outraged. They have fought with each other all their lives, and they still do; but they make common cause to try to rescue their father and what might be left of their inheritance. In the course of the story we are given glimpses of the history of Ukraine, the terrible sufferings of the civil war, the terror and the famine of the Stalin years, the Second World War, a labour camp; also of the development of tractors - those symbols of the collective farms, of which the old man, a former engineer, is writing a history. Towards the end, the book becomes a near farce, and then modulates into a happier ending than we had any reason to expect. We are even allowed for a moment to see the monstrous gold-digger as herself a victim, too. The descriptions of the individuals and the relationships between them is excellent, the somewhat fractured English spoken by the old man and the even more primitive but expressive mauling of it by Valentina is spot-on. A memorable book.
|
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Funny and satisfying!, 27 May 2006
This book is a quirky tale of a feisty and disjointed family. It has wildy comic moments and also very sobering educational glimpses into the histories of the characters, and a historical background into Ukrainian 20th century history (which I knew little about prior to reading this).
I enjoyed this book as it doesn't try to be anything grandiose, yet it is moving and also very funny - moments with the family that all of us can relate to in some way. The father is infuriating and selfish much of the time. However, I often felt sorry for him throughout the story as he is so blind to the deceptions and reality of the predicaments that he gets himself into.
I usually go for much grittier stories which are often harder to get to grips with and sometimes, try as I might, I just don't always "get it"! I was pleased to discover that this book was much more impressive than I expected and I enjoyed every page - Its a real page turner!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|