Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
22 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Series which Broke the Mould, 15 Feb 2006
A novel which broke the mould, reinvented the concept of Space Opera and begot a minor cult, as groundbreaking novels are wont to do.
It’s rather spooky to look at Dune again in the light of the Iraq War, since we have in this book a situation where a desert people are militarily outclassed and dominated by a Superpower which wishes to retain control over the desert’s vital resource.
In this case it isn’t control of oil which is being fought over, but the melange spice of Arrakis, just as vital to transportation between stars as oil is for transportation between cities.
One could possibly compare the USA with the Evil Empire of Shaddam (even that name has a spooky resonance, but with the wrong side) and the planet Arrakis with the Middle East, but one would have to examine Arab-American relations in the Nineteen Sixties to get much mileage from that.
Undeniably, the Fremen are essentially Arabic in flavour, but he rest of Galactic Society is based around a feudal aristocratic system of powerful Houses, presided over by the Emperor Shaddam. It is an aggressive and brutal system in which assassination and treachery are rife.
Interlacing this network of families is the Sisterhood of the Bene Gesserit, an organisation which has its own reasons for an intense interest in the melange spice, a strange organic substance which can endow its users with a form of prescience and telepathy.
Another major player in the politics of the galaxy is the Spacer’s Guild, a professional group of mutated humans who use the properties of the spice to sense changes in space and steer ships through hyperspace across the galaxy. They are also bound into the political web which is battling for control of Arrakis, since without the spice, which can only be found on Arrakis, the guildsmen would be useless, and traffic throughout the galaxy would come to a halt.
Herbert skilfully stage-manages the political manoeuvring and chicanery which may or may not be being controlled from behind the scenes by the Sisterhood. Thus it seems as though politics itself conspires to set in motion the events leading to the fulfilment of a Bene Gesserit prophesy.
Ironically, the religion which is integral to Fremen life contains elements implanted centuries before by the Bene Gesserit in order that the Sisterhood would be welcomed by their society. Thus, the Fremen, like the Sisterhood themselves, also know of the prophecy of the Kwisatz Hadderach.
It’s a clever trick on Herbert’s part, as the coming of the Superior Being can be seen as both the unexpected culmination of a long term Bene Gesserit plan, or the true fulfilment of a long religious expectation on the part of the Fremen.
It’s not by any means an anti-religious book, although it is realistic about the nature of organised religion. It shows that religious systems are, by their very nature, political systems, or at least are tied into the political structures within which they exist.
Herbert’s universe of techno-feudalism is so well realised the reader feels quite at ease with the absurd and anachronistic ideas of Dukes and Barons wielding power over dominions of planets. There is a pervasive atmosphere of decadence and unhealthy opulence (particularly with regard to the House Harkonnen whose Baron is a corpulent gay monster who revels in the sexual gratification derived from the dying throes of his young victims) which is contrasted with the simple yet disciplined lives of the Fremen.
If you've never read these books, then start now. Travel to another world. Enjoy!
|
|
|
9 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best Science Fiction book I have ever read, 5 Sep 2006
I bought this book on the recommendation of a friend, not being particularly interested in the Science Fiction genre at all.
In fact "Dune" was the first real Science Fiction book I read, my previous literary experience being steeped in the genre of Fantasy from the likes of J.R.R. Tolkein and Terry Pratchett.
I was very surprised about just how much I enjoyed this book, and I'd advise anyone that isn't into Sci-Fi and thinks it's just lasers and robots to immediately reconsider.
"Dune" is quite epic in style and atmosphere, although like many groundbreaking novels it does not seem thus at the start. I find Arthur C. Clarke's words on "Dune" quite relevant at this moment:
"[Dune is] Unique among SF novels...I know nothing comparable to it except "The Lord of the Rings""
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A must read, 29 April 2008
This contains "Dune", "Dune Messiah", "Children of Dune."
This should keep any sci-fi fan occupied for a while. This is an amazing trilogy which really re-invented the genre of space science fiction. Set on the desert planet of Arrakis thousands of years in the future this epic trilogy follows Paul Atreidies and his family. It is packed with complex plots and intricately woven storylines spanning decades. Initially Dune is about the feuds between the houses Harkonnen (vile baddies) and the Atreidies (noble goodies) and the scheming Bene Gesserit sisterhood. And the spice of course...the spice....controls everything. But it pans out into a search for a new messiah....
This is hard to review as there is so much to say. It is amazing to see a future so distant, people are beyond using computers (they got too clever). There is an intriguing blend of politics, religion, economics and rebellion.
Utterly engrossing, my favourite space epic!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Frank Herbert
by Frank Herbert
by Frank Herbert
by Brian Herbert
by Brian Herbert
