Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
110 of 112 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Guide to Non-Manipulative Parenting, 3 April 2002
Don't be put off by the unflattering title of this book, as it teaches value guided parenting and shows the reader what a healthy functional family looks like. The authors study the common traits in families that produce healthy well adapted children, shedding light on the many parenting myths and misconceptions which todays parents are inundated with. There are many different types/styles of families and cultures which consitantly raise successful children, but they all share certain virtues or common qualities. They show why the current tendency of lowering expectations/standards, combined with a "child-centered" approach, is so detrimental to a childs self esteem, encouraging children to under perform like never before.The book is NOT about any particular type of child as the title suggests, but focuses on teaching parents to become 'manipulation proof' by understanding their own weaknesses and blind spots. These 'hidden agendas' include things such as parental guilt, fear, lack of confidence, inconvenience, conflict between parents etc. Through their normal limit testing, kids quickly discover and can exploit our blind sides without really understanding or comprehending why we tend to react in predictable ways. Parents must first look at themselves and find out what is preventing them from being effective when it comes to discipline. Many books accurately describe discipline problems and give sound situational advice but this one actually explains why some behaviours persist with seemingly no reward or purpose. Why a child will initiate a three hour screaming power struggle when all he/she has to do is pick up one toy or write one sentence of homework. We could not understand why our child was so focused on controlling us with no real purpose or goal and this book explains it very clearly. This is one of only a few parenting books which give a good explaination of unwanted behavours learned through "negative reinforcement". This is so important because the most challenging behaviours are not positively rewarded, but rooted or acquired through negative reinforcement. These are behaviours which are not always deliberate or conciously guided, with 'avoidance' as the underlying goal. Because they are rooted in avoidance they are much more persistant and enduring than behaviours acquired through positive reinforcement. When most people hear the word "Manipulation" they automatically think of openly planned deception, but that is NOT what this book is about. Many negatively reinforced behaviours appear manipulative on the surface but actually have no real goal or reward other than avoidance. When there is mutual avoidance or 'hidden agendas' with both the parent and child, that's where the problems start. The book teaches parents to recognise these patterns, and interrupt them before they become your childs normal mode of operation. This is an excellent book and surely a real eye-opener for many parents. It's not your typical "how to" parenting book but gives parents a powerful insight into healthy family dynamics. If your child is excessively bossy, controlling, always trying to make others compromise (for no apparent reason), expending a disproportionate amount of energy over seemingly trivial issues or objectives, READ THIS BOOK! Other great discipline/parenting books I highly recommend are: "Setting Limits" by Robert J MacKenzie, "Ain't Misbehavin" by William P Garvey, "Kid Cooperation" by Elizabeth Pantley and "How to Talk so Kids will Listen and Listen so Kids Will Talk".
|
|
|
33 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
looking at the root causes, not papering over the cracks, 4 Mar 2004
By A Customer
We went on holiday with friends and their families. One day i watched 8 children being coached, bribed, threatened and applauded by at least 8 adults through a simple evening meal. Eating is a good example of the complex emotions and behaviours which are experienced by parents and their children. Adults worry whether they are eating enough, eating the right things, sitting straight. children get hungry and eat but are affected by the attention that they can get if they play around, or refuse to eat.This book does start slowly, but is an essential insight into the way we parent today. It has changed our family life completely. I never shout, never punish and never reach those heights of frustration which would make me need to leave the room to scream and cry. The stop and pause technique gives ME a chance to stop and calm down as much as it does my son. Our household is not perfect, but I now feel in control, and the children know i am in control, which makes them infinitely happier. I no longer dread the children having friends to play. My son no longer bites his nails. The biggest problem with this book is the title, i nearly didn't buy it as it seemed rather negative (until you understand what the authors are trying to tell you). I have passed it on to friends, but many people seem to find it hard to get through. Those most in need, have the biggest problem getting their heads around it!
|
|
|
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
no advice, just theoretical, very dissapointing, 7 Jan 2006
I am beginning to think the posititve reviews at amazon are either made up or not worth much because i bought this book on the basis of such reviews and boy was i dissapointed. The authors spend three chapters defining manipulative (they mean naughty) and say that ranges from children crying when they cant read a book to children walking suggestively!! It is totally based on theories and over simplistic case studies which i personally thought were made up. Whats worse is that the authors spend one chapter on how to stop children being manipulative, they dont explain how to do it AT ALL.The book is full of the autors self congratulating themselves for being so clever, they dont agree with positive parenting, but instead agree with positive practice, even though they dont say what that is. If you're looking for sound advice, this is not the book for you. It is also totally for the american market. The authors idea of stopping children messing about at school (explain their approach to teachers and ask them to do it in the parents absence) is totally laughable. "Setting limits on your stong willed child" is a much better book!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|