An even better read than the original, 10 Dec 2004

By	Antonio Pineda (UK) - See all my reviews

Meanwhile, the Resistance continue to perform thefts and raids in their effort to to expose magicians as unfit to govern. Adding to the strange mix is a golem inflicting a series of terrifying attacks on the capital, a monster who may be under the control of a senior politician. Nathaniel finds himself being charged with the task of getting to the bottom of things to protect the government ... and save his career at the same time.

Like its preceding volume in The Bartimaeus Trilogy, The Golem's Eye is a fast-paced and entertaining read that is sure to delight Stroud's growing army of fans. This time round, the narrative switches between three viewpoints and not just two: those of Nathaniel and Bartimaeus (as in the first book) and Kitty, a member of the Resistance. This makes for a more balanced brew.

The expansion of Kitty's role (a character who made only a brief appearance in the first novel), is the main reason why I think this sequel is a better book than the original. The story is no longer told through the eyes of a magician and a creature of magic, but also through the eyes of a commoner and a female one at that. The Amulet of Samarkand, though an excellent start of the trilogy, suffered from not having a strong female character and a perspective outside the world of magicians and the elite. The Golem's Eye addresses these flaws.

If Bartamaeus stole the limelight from Nathaniel in The Amulet of Samarkand, Kitty has the same effect in The Golem's Eye. She develops into a more polished and likable character than Nathaniel as flashbacks into her past reveal the reasons behind her hatred of magicians and how she joined the Resistance. Her character arouses such poignancy that many readers will find themselves cheering for her and not Nathaniel by the end of the book.

Indeed, if there's one criticism I can make on this sequel, it's the fact that Nathaniel's character becomes "just another magician" whose main aim in life is to amass great power and influence. On occasions, I became indifferent to what happened to him as I rushed through the chapters concerning him so that I could find out what happens next to Kitty.

Fans of Bartimaeus, however, will not be disappointed. He is as sharp-tongued and witty as ever and his footnotes - while they can disrupt the flow of the narrative - still have the power to send you laughing out loud. So you have been warned: don't read this book in a places where being quiet is a requirement.

I sure hope Stroud is busy working hard on the third (and final) installment. I can't wait to read it.

Review by Antonio Pineda

 Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

Golem's Eye Will Catch the Reader's Eye, 8 Oct 2004

This book is spectacular...I can't describe it. It's from the view of three different characters, Nathaniel, Bartimaeus, and the young spunky member of the Resistance, Kitty Jones. It also contains one particular chapter which features Simpkin, a foliot from the first book who dies. Mr. Stroud, that was a nice touch to the story and a tribute to Simpkin who I will miss (too bad Bartimaeus didn't kill him off...).

The title, The Golem's Eye, refers to an enourmous clay man called a golem which is controlled by the golem's eye, a clay eye set in the middle of a golem's forehead in which a magician can control it with a regular crystal ball or orb.

I could go on hours and hours complimenting this book...but for now I must stop. I can't wait for The Other Place and of course, the Amulet of Samarkand movie!

 Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)