|
63 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best I've Seen, 19 Mar 2002
By A Customer
I absolutely love this book. If my first encounter with it had been in a store though, I might have put it back on the shelf quickly. At first glance, it looks dated and lacks the glossy colour pages and multi-media bells and whistles of most self-study materials today. As I first came across it on Amazon though, I was influenced by the consistently glowing reviews, rather than my own shallow prejudices. One review here poses the question, why haven't other language teachers caught on to this method? I would say that Madrigal's approach is broadly similar to that used by Michel Thomas in his equally valuable cassette/CD based course. (If you're interested in that, I'd strongly recommend buying the full course and not just the 2hr introductory version). Both of them take the approach of introducing the language via cognates, which encourage you to feel that you know some Spanish already. It is a great way to engage the student who may be doubtful as to their own abilities to learn another language. The other significant similarity is that they both passionately believe in the student actively "creating" the language for themselves, rather than learning things parrot fashion. The latter approach, as I can attest from my time at school, means that you are likely to retain very little of the language and even less of your enthusiasm to study it. I've been amazed at how different the study of Spanish seems using these resources, compared with how things were during secondary education. Back in those dark days, it was all rote learning of vocab lists and endless verb conjugation drills. You still have to learn the structure of the language using Madrigal's book and/or Thomas' cassettes, but in both cases the process is fun - you're not introduced to the language in a dry manner, devoid of application. You find yourself doing something which is stimulating, creative and confidence-building. How different from that sense of banging one's head against a brick wall. As I say, I'd highly recommend the Michel Thomas course. However, some people - myself being one of them - may be a little disconcerted with it being audio only and would appreciate a text to consolidate their learning. Madrigal's Magic key is excellent for that purpose.
|