Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A thoughtful and serious novel of teenage self-discovery. Carnegie Medal winner in 1999., 25 Sep 2008
`Growing up is, after all, only the understanding that one's unique and incredible experience is what everyone shares.' (Doris Lessing, "The Golden Notebook"). - a quote taken from one of the chapter headings; snippets that Jacob's grandmother sends to him each week on a postcard.
With one central theme - the theme of love - there are two main stories to follow. Primarily, the story is about 17-year-old Jacob Todd from England, who lives with his grandmother Sarah, and is now visiting the Netherlands for the first time for the commemoration of the Battle of Arnhem, where his grandfather fought in the Second World War. Jacob is visiting a Dutch family, at his grandmother's request, as she has hurt her hip and is unable to travel for the Arnhem commemorations. The eldest member of the family is the terminally ill Geertrui, and it's Geertrui's story of her experiences during the war that make up the other story throughout the novel.
Jacob begins his holiday with mixed feelings. He feels like an intruder into Geertrui's family, a stranger in a strange place. Even his long-held love for Anne Frank, through obsessive reading of her Diary, feels different after he has visited her house in Amsterdam. Jacob's brief holiday becomes a journey of self-discovery, encountering a gay friend, an elderly lady he befriends when she helps him after he is mugged, the liberal lifestyle of Daan (the son of the family he is visiting), the emotions of the Arnhem commemorations and his encounter with a girl to whom he feels instantly attracted, not to mention his exploration of the subject of euthanasia after meeting the terminally ill Geertrui. Through all of his experiences, Jacob finds he has begun to fall in love with the city of Amsterdam itself.
Where Jacob's story is one of discovery, Geertrui's story of her time as a young woman during the occupation is one of intensity, and living each day one day at a time. Geertrui's story is told in the first person, looking back from her elderly years to the most significant time of her life. Geertrui makes you feel and live those days with her. Her worries are your worries; the immediacy of war is brought vividly to the reader to share and experience with the young Geertrui. Of her story - well, you must read the book to find out more!
A very rewarding read for sophisticated teens, especially those beginning to question the world and how they fit into the whole. Exploration of themes of sexuality, morals, personality, appearances, life, death, friendships and more, show how there is a place for everyone, however different. I would recommend the book for ages 12+, adults included.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Its been a long time....., 26 May 2002
By A Customer
....since i read this book and i have only read it once as, like the teacher who reviewed the book, i only met it through it being up for the award and our school was reviewing the nominees. I was a pupil who, begrudgingly at first, agreed to read this book. The first few chapters were very drawn out and boring, and i did consider quitting reading it, thankfully i carried on. Although to be honest i can't remember a whole lot about the minor details in the book, i remember the plot, the language, the emotions in the book, and above all i remember how it made me feel when i was reading it..enlightened..i think would be a good word to use. These memories alone, to me, warrent the five stars i have awarded it. Its one of the few books that have ever made me feel anything, and sit down after i had finished reading it and actually think about what i had just read, and my own particular views on wider issues.How can anyone say this book is not responsible becasue it talks about sex and euthenasia to teenagers, that is a pathetic comment straight out of the dark ages. For any liberated people out there, mature enough to handle the topics the book talks about and the emotions it conveys, this is a must read.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two brilliant stories entwined, 20 Feb 2004
This book is aimed at young adults, but its themes and language mean that it is not restricted in any upper age limit. The book entwines the story of a teenager being released into Amsterdam with a war time recount of a personal relationship behind the front line. The book is well written, although I feel that the modern day story is far better and has a tendancy to dominate the novel. The modern day story would stand up to being a stand alone novel. The link between the two stories is slightly tenuous and it does feel slightly contrived, however, the book is still a very enjoyable read. Perfect holiday reading.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Aidan Chambers
by Aidan Chambers
by Aidan Chambers
by Mal Peet
by Beverley Naidoo
