|
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, 12 April 2001
I recently got a copy of the Essential Guide to Alien Species ... and my fears came true. From the moment I heard about this book, I feared the worst. I do want to point out that I own all 3 West End Games Alien Books (Galaxy Guide 4 & 12 + Alien Encounters).This book is only good for people who don't have any previous Alien Books. I consider this volume a wasted opportunity to give the +/- 35 species from the movies, that have not yet gotten their background, a decent place in the Universe. There are +/- 65 Species and Creatures from the movies and +/- 73 from the Expanded Universe in this book, so you can hardly call this book Essential, since we've all seen the movies, but not all of us have read the books / comics. What's bad about this book: *Hardly contains any real new information, most info is copied from previous books and it seems there wasn't any real interest (enough knowledge of Star Wars lore) to write new information. *Episode I species are ignored. Only Toydarians, Dugs, Neimoidians and Gungans appear in this book. So don't expect to see species of the Jedi Council, Senate or Podracers. *Way too much Expanded Universe ! Even (many) Marvel Aliens show up in this book ! *Mixing Aliens with Creatures is not a good idea. The results are clear. There are missing creatures from the movies (not even one creature from Episode I is in this book!) and there are missing many Species as well. I bought this book because I really like the alien species from the movies and because I thought they would finally give some species a proper background ... I wonder if the writer has actually seen the movies more than once. I think she has never heard of Lutrillians, Wol Cabashhite, Troig, Iktotchi or Morseerian. I think it's a pity that when you're allowed to write a Star Wars Sourcebook that you don't grab the opportunity to write new information instead rehearsing old info. And that she was allowed to add new info was proved because there is a little bit new info though (H'Nemthe - Kowakian Monkey Lizards - Gundarks and Yarkora). I rated it as "3" because it's useful to fans who don't have any previous alien books, but almost useless to fans who do have them.
|