|
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining, but probably the worst in the series, 5 Dec 2004
The sixth "Merrily Watkins" book is an enjoyable read, but the series shows signs of flagging. Merrily's newly-instituted Sunday Evening Services have gained a reputation as "healing" services, and she is asked to help a man with asthma - but his problems lie far deeper. Her daughter Jane has started a new job at Stanner Hall, whose new owner hopes to turn it into a thriving hotel - based on his theory that Arthur Conan Doyle once stayed there, and that many local legends were combined to form the basis of "The Hound of the Baskervilles". Meanwhile local farmer Jeremy Berrows finds love with a woman with a mysterious past... Phil Rickman has toned down his style a little - not every chapter/section ends on a cliff-hanger, but this tends to slow the pace somewhat. He hasn't given up his annoying habit of cranking up the tension (which he does admirably) without giving the reader the "pay off" - the story will jump to after the action, with dialogue filling in what happened. The supernatural element is toned down yet further too; it's almost as if he has his eye on a Sunday night ITV adaptation (one has been mooted). This is probably great for the general public (six books with a seventh in the works is good going!), but not so good for genre fans, who will probably feel cheated. I also felt that elements of the main plot covered a lot of the same ground as the 5th (far superior) book, which had the added benefit of being based on a real person. On a lighter note, I wish he hadn't named the Jamaican priest "Jeavons", as I kept visualising actor Colin Jeavons (especially after catching him playing Lestrade in a Holmes dramatisation recently!). Well worth a read if you've been following the series, as there are some nice developments between Lol and Merrily, but by far the weakest entry in the series to date. I'd like to see Rickman either phase out the supernatural element entirely, turning the series into a sharper, sexier "Father Doyle Mysteries", or (preferably) to put pedal to the metal and go all out on the supernatural front. It would be cool if he was lulling his audience into a false sense of security for a killer climax to the series, but I suspect that he's not going to kill his cash cow.
|