Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
the world's longest serving head of state - a politcal book - not the best written, 16 May 2009
Bhumibol Adulyadej - known as Rama IX. in the western world - reigns since 9 June 1946. He is the world's longest-serving current head of state and the longest-serving monarch in Thai history.
This book is banned in Thailand as it seems to be a case for lèse majesté, the law which allow anyone insulting him or questioning his roles in politics to be jailed for 3 to 15 years. Even tough in his 2005 birthday speech, Bhumibol said he would not take lèse majesté seriously, charges are still often pressed.
The book deals with the political aspects of his reign. Although King Bhumibol is a constitutional monarch, it makes it clear that the king intervened several times decisively in Thai politics. Not that is a real surprise if one follows a bit world politics. But this seems to be incontradiction of the official line of a king above politics. But Thailand is not a constitutional monarchy in the western sense. Therefore the book was banned as its "contents which could affect national security and the good morality of the people."
I am not at all for preventing publications of books. Freedom of expression and freedom of publications is essential.
Besides this point is that a good book:
The ups and downs of Thai politics are interesting, but far too detailed and in style make often extremely tedious reading. To be honest I jumped a few pages. The book gives the reader an introduction into the Royal House and Family, but much is missing. It would have been great if there would have been a simplified family tree and an explanation of Thai titles. There are no photos at all. The RF and the relationship in particular of King and Queen is not really fully explored. The Queen features as a political force too, but that is not even fully described and explained. . The last chapter on the RF and the furture of the dynatsy are better and clearly pointed out why none of the King's children is really meeting the expectations.
The mystery of the King Ananda's death remains excatly that.The author just puts a few questionmarks to it, which is not at all new. The king remained the constant in politcs and taking into account the deep divisions in Thai politics seems to be a stabilizing factor. This aspect is however less observed and explored by the author. Of course it deals with certain myths about the King and the RF and takes the rational point of view to it. Point very well taken, but don't we do that with our western monarchs as well? Do we accept a certain myth about them? I suppose we do. So what is needed is perspective here and that is missing.
All in all, it is a book helping discussion, but not the last word on this king. In style I found it trying. So I suppose this is a book one must not have read.
|
|
|
22 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
New Perspective to a Thai, 21 Sep 2006
As someone who spent my childhood in upcountry Thailand, went to state schools there and later in Bangkok and had an advance degree from a US University, I thought i would share with my countrymen how we perceive the King. My conversations with friends, colleagues, and most of the comments here by Thai readers/reviewers say I was totally wrong.
The book hits the nail in its head when it says that most thai my generation (I was born in the turbulent year 1976, when the right-wing government crushed student protestors and the King declared the event "the saddest day in Thai history") have always seen the King in the best of lights - and it was not something that wasn't well-planned by someone. In retrospect, I agree with the author about how the palace has orchestrated all their efforts on setting the royals in the best of lights, i.e. making all the royal projects look far more important and successful than their real worths by downplaying efforts by governments, presenting the royals in the way of super-human, in every aspect possible. When I was a young adult, I did not have a second thought about what the media was protraying the king and the royal family, i accepted it as truths and I don't have any reason to believe that most of my countrymen would see things otherwise - everything was so grand, so well orchestrated and thus so believeable.
One notable point that I think Handley sums up the sentiment of many Thai very nicely is when he briefly discussed another biography on King Bhumibol "The Revolutionary King" (which I also read several years back) that it was probably for the consumption of a small group of educated Thais who tend to be more ready to accept what's written in English than those written in Thai (for several reasons, for one, they believe the author can escape the lesse majeste by saying negative things about the King in English) My view about the King has always been similar to the one protrayed in "The Revolutionary King", which puts the King as a very capable person though with some minor flaws - which make it easier to swallow than "The Perfect One" image that the Palace media has always been projecting. Deep down, I believe, many Thais think of the King as human, yet a very respectable one (though many choose to live with the fairy tale that he is a true semi-god), so when we hear negative minor points about him, we think it could all be possible and make him even more humane yet more likable. This could be the original purpose of the "Revolutionary King" - reinforcing the King's image to the elite Thai lot. The book was written by the person who wrote "The Man called Intreprid" which was translated by the King himself.
Overall, Handley convincingly argue his case that things could be looked at in a very different perspective. He backs up his arguements with well-researched evidence many anecdotes the average Thai would have heard of. For me I haven't heard of just about half (probably more for even younger people), the others are totally new to me.
I highly recommend this book to any Thai who want to understand the country and the monarchy better, in a more objective way. This book doesn't make me love the country and the King less. It makes me understand the King better, in a more realistic way.
I also recommend an academic piece by McCargo "Network Monarchy" if you find this book interesting.
|
|
|
13 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good read and thought-provoking, 10 Oct 2006
Without a doubt, this book is banned in Thailand. I just got back from England and found out that my mother is totally pissed just because Handley is American and he writes a book about the king. She kept saying that he does not know anything. I am certain my mother is not the only one who has the same sort of super-positive thinking about the King.
I am a new generation--the generation in which the king has been re-portrated as a semi-god since the bloodshed events in the 1970's. However, interestingly, as Handley has tried to illustrate in his well-written book, the fact that in Thailand the king 'can do no wrong' is a ubiquitous thought (and it was surely brought about by the notion of the king as a sacred non-political icon)among the Thai populace, the King and the Palace have chosen to inject the simple yet strong notion of the King as a 'scholar', 'musician', 'initiative' so on and so forth. This is how the King could simply survive a number of political crisis in the past. Thailand in the 21th century in terms of its national stregnth, has been therefore taken for granted to survive, almost entirely, 'by' the King.
As a journalist, Handley cannot write as biographers do and, indeed, there are much less references than it should have. The book, nonetheless, is highly recommended as a thought-provoking tool and for those who live in Thailand and want to escape from the everyday-repeated message in the Palace News. I agree with Khun Saraburian that the book does not make me love the King less. I do not care if the past and the events have flawed him in any ways. As the centre of all the Thais' heart, he is worth admiring and prasing.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|