|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
comprehensive and interesting, 10 Aug 2004
By A Customer
At last I found the kind of book about dreams I was looking for! I wanted a scientific explanation of dreaming; why for instance it is dificult to remember dreams, or why everything feels so enriched with meaning. Too many books I had previously read relied on Freud's or Jung's ideas, lacking any contempory knowledge of the mind. This does not.It is written by someone who is passionate about dreaming and who believes it carries meaning - something which many scientists disregard - and it also covers lucid dreaming (though only briefly). I liked how he broke dreaming down into several factors such as bizarreness and emotional intensity, explained why these occur, and how these could be benificial. However, Hobson (the author) does not believe in content analysis (a psychoanalytic dream analysis for instance) and believes that the emotion attached to the dream is far more important. Hobson does not dispute symbolism in dreams, but does not believe the narratives are so complex they need to be interpreted by some trianed proffessional. I personally believe you do occassionaly need the help of someone else, and that dreams are not always as transient as Hobson tends to suggest. As someone who has a passionate interest in my own dreams, however, I did not find the science of the book to contradict with my own experience - quite the opposite. The book covers so much that I do not have room to write about it all here, but what I will say is that unless you are looking for black and white answers in the form those pointless 'dream dictionaries,' you could do much worse then this book. I would also suggest 'the right way to interpret dreams' by Dr scott, as some things covered in this are not covered by Hobson. Regarding symbolism: Pierre Daco is good, though it is more tradional in it's approach to the mind. It has however made me particularly aware of my own dream symbols.
|