Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Everything is Unbearablely Smart , 30 Mar 2008
Everything is Unbearably Smart.
This novel I picked up with out any preconceptions, and without anything to colour my interpretations. But there was a lot of praise printed in and on the covers, and Elijah Wood looked out at me from front image, so as I started I anticipated an interesting read, worthy of not scant praise, and a film interpretation, and that it was, in places.
I'll be honest when I say that by the end I was willing it to finish. I was tired of Safran Foer's typographic gymnastics, and the rambling narrative. There are moments of cutting poignancy, and occasions when I was charmed by the clever prose. But the charm of the character Alex's broken English wears off - it just becomes labourious, a critisicm that could be levied against the whole book. Safran Foer seems to take great pleasure in twisting up syntax and grammar, idiom, turn of phrase, and turning it on its head. Sometimes his sentences are so inward looking they seem palindromic. You read it and think, 'Well that's a smart bit of linguistic contortion, but I hate you for putting my through it, page after page, chapter after chapter'. By the end of this book, I was blinded from the posthumously evident sadness and power of the narrative because of the tortuous language use. Don't get me wrong, I'm no prescriptivist when it comes to language use, but I get the feeling with this book that Safran Foer isn't playing with language for the good of the story, but for his own cryptic pleasure.
So this morning I finished the book, and I sighed with relief. I think this author is a brave one, and perhaps greatness will follow, but this was not a masterwork.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great premise, 29 Nov 2007
If the premise of EVERYTHING IS ILLUMINATED doesn't grab you from the beginning, you're dead from the neck up: A young man, named Jonathan Safran Foer, travels to the Ukraine to find the person who saved his grandfather. This sets him on a journey that is filled with humour, sadness, family secrets, and total weirdness that all meshes together to make a complete and satisfying whole. More than a few have commented on this being very "Marquez-like" in that it transports the reader back to the eighteenth century in parts and has a dream-like quality. Alex Perchov, another character in the book, narrates part of Foer's history as he doubles as tour guide, sounding stragely like "Borat" at times, and just about as funny. Told with multiple voices, I was reminded of the nove Bark of the Dogwood more than once, not only for this reason but because the narrator in that book delves back into his own family's history in much the same way. EVERYTHING IS ILLUMINATED is a one-of-a-kind book, and Foer is an American genius.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
31 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Everything is hype-enated, 9 Aug 2004
If you dare to set foot in any bookshop, you will find yourself confronted by the flashy cover of this book. Its eyes will follow you around the room. Looking inside the jacket, you will find yourself bludgeoned into buying it by snatches of effusive praise from what seems like a thousand learned people. The funniest quotation is the one that hysterically compares the author's use of language with that of Anthony Burgess in 'A Clockwork Orange'. Burgess utilised his linguistic prowess in that book to create a convincing style of language with the careful use of various forms of slang and words of Russian origin. The author here takes one joke - an imitation of the poor English ability of a Ukrainian - and stretches it over the whole book. The effect is sometimes relatively funny, but it is much closer, in terms of quality, originality and intellectual content, to Avid Merrion in 'Bo Selector' than it is to Burgess's classic novel. The sections set in the past are sometimes quite moving, but they are tainted slightly by a grating authorial cleverness that is always too overtly apparent in the writing. For me, cleverness in a book should be behind the scenes, unnoticeable, driving the story without getting in the way. There are also instances of embarrassing pretentiousness, such as the long passage about people making love creating a light visible from the heavens. 'Everything is Illuminated' is the work of a promising new author who may or may not produce a good novel in the future. The overenthusiastic praise for this book is bemusing, and it suggests that the American literary scene is so starved that the critics have been driven hysterical with the need for a saviour. In the words of Public Enemy, 'Don't believe the hype'.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Jonathan Safran Foer
![Everything Is Illuminated [DVD] [2005]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/519V2KXSF1L._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Elijah Wood
by Nicole Krauss
by Jorge Semprun
by Jonathan Safran Foer
