Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A most interesting read, 29 Jun 2003
By A Customer
I couldn't put this down, and really got in to the characters and settings, so much so that I didn't think to wonder about the two stories, and why she was telling them juxtaposed although nearly 100 years separated them. So I was caught by surprise at the end, and didn't find the neatly 'wrapped-up ending' at all annoying or distracting--it solved the mystery!In one way, I found the chapter organisiation a bit distracting as I wanted to keep going with one set of characters but then the book would not have worked otherwise as the whole point was to contrast the lives and social setup of the characters. It certainly points up the differences between attitudes to childcare, single parents, adoption, of 100 years ago, 50 years ago and now--something I havn't had to think much about. Well worth reading.
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Intriguing subject, well-written, 20 Nov 2001
This book was lent to me quite some time ago, and I was at first reluctant to read it. Having read the blurb on the cover, I concluded it wasn't the sort of book I would have chosen in a shop. But I finally got it started and was rewarded with a thoroughly satisfying novel. Some people may not like the way in which the narrative "jumps around" in time, from the turn of the century to the sixties/seventies, but I found the story (or, rather, the four stories) was developed at just the right tempo. By switching between her four main characters - two mothers and their "abandoned" daughters -, Forster manages to reveal just enough of the story in each chapter to keep the pace going, but not so much that you tire of the characters. The characters themselves are believable and engaging enough to be able to frustrate and disappoint me when they did not react as I would have liked (which is always a good indication of well-developed characters). This is certainly a character-driven novel, exploring the consequences of choices, the reactions of those affected by these choices, and the consequences of these reactions. It is also a telling comparison of the evolution of social attitudes in the UK to illegitimate children and single parents from the end of the 1800s to the second half of the twentieth century. First is Evie, abandoned by her mother at an early age, a girl whose worldly belongings amount to barely more than the clothes she stands in, who has no family to speak of save for some far-away cousins who give her a home but expect her to work (very hard) as a maid and general skivvy to earn her keep. Compared to this poor soul, Shona, born in the late fifties and adopted at birth by a childless couple who (especially her mother) lavish her with love and care, is far more fortunate than she appreciates.
All in all, this is an interesting book which deserves a second read. I also appreciated the twist towards the end, which fits nicely into a "tidy" ending that does not leave the reader wondering "what happens to so-and-so...?".
Probably not one for the men-folk, it's very much a woman's book!
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Explores Feelings of Parents and Adopted Children, 23 Nov 2002
I was adopted as a child, at the age of six (both parents killed in a car accident when I was four). I found this story of two orphaned children to be well worth reading. I enjoyed it more than another book by the same author, Hidden Lives. What I enjoyed most was looking at how the two mothers felt about their illegitimate children, and how the two daughters felt about having been abandoned. It explores all four of these women's lives and feelings for the entire course of all four women's lives. I was fortunate to remember my real mother, and have people tell me about my real parents. This book made me reflect on the various possiblities of how different parents and children react to adoption, and I thought it was quite realistically done, even though all four women's cases were drastically different from my own. It is a book that really explores lives and feelings.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Margaret Forster
by Margaret Forster
by Margaret Forster
by Margaret Forster
by Margaret Forster
